14 Underappreciated Romance Movies Worth Adding to Your List

Looking for a fresh take on romance? While popular love stories often dominate the spotlight, there are hidden gems that offer unique and unforgettable experiences. These films explore love in all its forms, sweet, complicated, and unexpected. Whether you’re in the mood for something quirky, heartfelt, or thought-provoking, these movies prove that great romance can come from the most unexpected places.

This post may contain affiliate links, which helps keep this content free. Please read our disclosure for more info.

“The Adjustment Bureau” (2011)

This movie follows David Norris (Matt Damon), a rising politician, who falls in love with Elise (Emily Blunt), a talented dancer. However, their love is continuously thwarted by mysterious agents who seem to control their fate. While the premise sounds like a typical sci-fi thriller, the romance in “The Adjustment Bureau” is deeply compelling. The film explores themes of destiny, choice, and the idea of a love so strong that it defies all forces, making it a standout despite being overlooked by audiences.

The chemistry between Damon and Blunt is undeniable, and their characters’ love story offers a rare blend of tension and tenderness. The plot may be overshadowed by the action and suspense elements, but the romantic undertones provide a beautiful balance. It’s a film that asks whether love is truly in our hands or if it’s part of a larger, uncontrollable design. “The Adjustment Bureau” deserves more attention for its thought-provoking themes and memorable performances.

“In Time” (2011)

“In Time” is set in a dystopian future where time has become the currency, and people stop aging at 25. Justin Timberlake plays Will Salas, a man who inherits a large amount of time and finds himself on the run with a rich young woman, Sylvia (Amanda Seyfried), after they are both targeted by the system. Though the film has a strong sci-fi component, the romance that develops between the two is the heart of the story. The love between them is not just about attraction but also about survival in a world that has commodified everything.

What sets this film apart from other romantic thrillers is how it uses its futuristic setting to comment on social inequality, all while developing a believable and heartfelt relationship. The romance here is built on the urgency of their circumstances, and Timberlake and Seyfried’s performances bring an emotional depth to the narrative. It’s an underrated gem that masterfully combines romance with a cautionary tale about societal values and the true meaning of time.

“Before We Go” (2014)

“Before We Go,” directed by and starring Chris Evans, is a heartwarming, intimate film about two strangers who meet by chance in New York City and spend one unforgettable night together. Brooke (Alice Eve) is stranded after missing her train, and Nick (Chris Evans) offers to help her get back home. As the night unfolds, they share their personal stories and form a bond that feels real and unforced. This film is a beautiful exploration of connection and timing, and the chemistry between Evans and Eve makes it all the more charming.

What makes “Before We Go” underrated is its simple, character-driven approach to romance. Unlike many romantic movies, it doesn’t rely on grand gestures or dramatic twists. Instead, it focuses on two people navigating their fears, regrets, and desires for one evening. It’s a quiet, thoughtful film that captures the fleeting magic of life’s unscripted moments, making it a must-watch for anyone who enjoys a more grounded and realistic love story.

“The Vow” (2012)

Starring Rachel McAdams and Channing Tatum, “The Vow” tells the story of a young couple whose marriage is put to the test when the wife, Paige, loses her memory in a car accident. Despite not remembering her husband, Leo, she struggles to reconnect with him as she rediscover her old life and identity. The movie explores the emotional depth of a relationship when one partner forgets the other, and how love can be rediscovered even after a traumatic event.

“The Vow” is often overlooked as just another romantic drama, but it offers a poignant look at love and the effort it takes to keep it alive, especially under challenging circumstances. The performances of McAdams and Tatum elevate the film, making the emotional moments feel raw and authentic. This movie reminds us that sometimes love isn’t just about the big moments, but the quiet persistence to keep fighting for the relationship, no matter the odds.

“Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind” (2004)

One of the most original romantic movies, “Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind,” follows Joel (Jim Carrey) and Clementine (Kate Winslet), who undergo a procedure to erase their memories of each other after a painful breakup. The film, directed by Michel Gondry, explores the complexities of relationships and the idea of erasing painful memories. At its core, it is a love story about two people trying to move on from each other but ultimately finding their way back, showing the importance of both the good and the bad experiences in making love meaningful.

What makes this film truly special is its innovative storytelling and the emotional depth brought by Carrey and Winslet. Their performances are vulnerable and layered, making this movie stand out as a unique take on the romantic genre. The concept of memory erasure might seem like a fantasy, but the emotional core of the film is grounded in the idea that true love cannot be erased, no matter how hard you try.

“Celeste and Jesse Forever” (2012)

This film stars Rashida Jones and Andy Samberg as a married couple who, despite getting a divorce, continue to navigate their personal and professional lives together. While most romantic movies focus on finding love, “Celeste and Jesse Forever” explores the complexities of ending a relationship and remaining friends. The movie takes an honest look at the process of moving on and the difficulty of letting go of someone you once loved deeply.

The dynamic between Jones and Samberg is genuine and humorous, with both actors bringing warmth and vulnerability to their roles. The film’s exploration of the emotional fallout from a divorce, combined with its witty dialogue, gives it a refreshing edge. “Celeste and Jesse Forever” might not be a conventional romance, but its nuanced portrayal of love and relationships makes it a truly underrated gem.

“Begin Again” (2013)

Starring Keira Knightley and Mark Ruffalo, “Begin Again” tells the story of two struggling musicians who find solace and inspiration in each other’s work. Knightley plays Gretta, a singer-songwriter who is heartbroken after a breakup with her famous musician boyfriend. Ruffalo’s character, Dan, is a washed-up music producer who sees the potential in Gretta’s music and offers to help her make an album. Though the film has music at its core, the developing bond between Gretta and Dan is the true heart of the story.

What makes “Begin Again” underrated is its ability to blend music and romance in an emotionally resonant way. The music is not only an essential part of the film, but it also mirrors the personal growth and healing the characters experience. The performances by Knightley and Ruffalo bring depth and authenticity to the story, making it a heartfelt and inspiring film about love, second chances, and finding a new beginning.

“Like Crazy” (2011)

“Like Crazy” is a deeply emotional film about two young people, Anna (Felicity Jones) and Jacob (Anton Yelchin), who fall in love while Anna is studying in the U.S. from the UK. Their relationship is tested when Anna overstays her visa, and they are forced to navigate the complexities of a long-distance relationship. The film’s raw portrayal of love, separation, and the passage of time makes it an underrated romance that doesn’t shy away from the real struggles relationships face.

The chemistry between Jones and Yelchin is palpable, and the film’s naturalistic style allows the audience to feel the uncertainty and heartache that comes with trying to keep love alive when life gets in the way. “Like Crazy” is a beautiful meditation on how distance and time can either strengthen or erode a relationship. It’s a quiet, powerful film that feels incredibly personal, making it a must-see for fans of realistic love stories.

“The Spectacular Now” (2013)

“The Spectacular Now” stars Shailene Woodley and Miles Teller as two high school seniors with very different outlooks on life who begin a relationship that challenges both of them. Sutter (Teller) is a carefree party boy who doesn’t believe in the future, while Aimee (Woodley) is a shy, responsible girl who has always put others first. Their relationship forces them to confront their own insecurities and personal growth, making the film a compelling coming-of-age romance.

What makes “The Spectacular Now” underrated is its honest portrayal of youthful relationships. It doesn’t idealize love, instead showing how difficult it can be to navigate life at a young age while dealing with personal baggage. The performances by Woodley and Teller are exceptional, bringing emotional depth to characters that could easily be stereotypical. This film is a perfect example of how love can shape you, even when it’s not always picture-perfect.

“Silver Linings Playbook” (2012)

Starring Bradley Cooper and Jennifer Lawrence, “Silver Linings Playbook” is a romantic comedy that dives deep into mental health issues, family dynamics, and second chances at love. Cooper plays Pat, a man recently released from a psychiatric hospital who is trying to win back his estranged wife. Along the way, he forms an unlikely bond with Tiffany (Lawrence), a woman struggling with her mental health issues. Together, they help each other face their demons and heal.

While it’s often categorized as a rom-com, “Silver Linings Playbook” is much more than that. It’s a raw, heartfelt exploration of how love can be messy, complicated, and imperfect. The film does an excellent job of portraying real human struggles, with both Cooper and Lawrence delivering standout performances. The film shows that love is not always easy, but it can be transformative when two people are willing to work through their issues together.

“The Half of It” (2020)

A modern retelling of the classic “Cyrano de Bergerac,” “The Half of It” follows Ellie (Leah Lewis), a shy, intelligent teenager who helps a classmate, Paul (Daniel Diemer), win the heart of a girl, Aster (Alexxis Lemire), whom Ellie secretly has feelings for. The film explores the complexities of love, identity, and friendship, presenting a nuanced look at unspoken emotions and personal growth. The subtle and quiet romance, combined with a refreshing take on LGBTQ themes, makes it a poignant and unique film.

What makes “The Half of It” underrated is its honest portrayal of unrequited love and self-discovery. Unlike typical high school romances, this film takes a more reflective approach, highlighting the internal battles of its characters rather than focusing on external romantic drama. The chemistry between Ellie and Aster is understated yet powerful, creating a slow-burn love story that lingers long after the credits roll.

“Chasing Amy” (1997)

Directed by Kevin Smith, “Chasing Amy” follows Holden (Ben Affleck) and Alyssa (Joey Lauren Adams), two comic book creators who begin a complicated romantic relationship. Holden falls in love with Alyssa, but her past and her sexuality create obstacles for their connection. The film examines themes of love, jealousy, and the complexities of sexuality in a way that feels fresh and mature for its time.

“Chasing Amy” is often overlooked in the romantic genre, perhaps due to its unconventional approach to love. The movie’s raw exploration of relationship dynamics and emotional vulnerability, paired with witty dialogue, sets it apart from more traditional romances. It dives deep into the characters’ emotional struggles, making it a movie that resonates with anyone who has experienced the challenges of love and self-acceptance.

“Ruby Sparks” (2012)

“Ruby Sparks” tells the story of Calvin (Paul Dano), a novelist who creates a fictional character named Ruby (Zoe Kazan), only to find that she comes to life in his apartment. As their relationship develops, Calvin faces the consequences of trying to control another person’s existence. The film explores themes of love, control, and the complexities of relationships, all wrapped in a whimsical and thought-provoking package.

What makes “Ruby Sparks” underrated is its clever twist on the romantic genre. The film starts with a fantastical premise but quickly turns into a profound exploration of the dangers of idealizing others. Dano and Kazan’s performances are both heartfelt and humorous, grounding the story’s surreal elements in emotional truth. This movie reminds us that love isn’t about perfection or control, but about accepting people for who they truly are.

“Tuck Everlasting” (2002)

Based on the beloved children’s novel, “Tuck Everlasting” follows the story of Winnie Foster (Alexis Bledel), a young girl who discovers a family that has been blessed with immortality. She becomes torn between a love for Jesse Tuck (Jonathan Jackson), a member of the immortal family, and the natural progression of life. The movie explores themes of love, life, and death, as Winnie must decide whether to join the Tucks or return to her normal life.

Though “Tuck Everlasting” is often seen as a young adult film, its underlying themes of love and sacrifice give it a timeless quality. The romance between Winnie and Jesse feels innocent yet deeply emotional, representing the fleeting nature of youth and the inevitability of change. The film’s melancholy and contemplative tone make it an underrated gem that resonates with audiences of all ages.

This article originally appeared on Avocadu.