10 TV Love Triangles That Had Audiences Picking Sides
Love triangles have always been a captivating storyline in TV dramas, leaving audiences divided and emotionally invested in the characters’ relationships. From passionate conflicts to heartbreaking decisions, these love triangles have sparked intense debates and fan loyalty. Whether it’s the emotional pull of two lovers competing for one person’s heart or the unexpected twists that challenge romantic expectations, these stories continue to capture the hearts of viewers.
This post may contain affiliate links, which helps keep this content free. Please read our disclosure for more info.
Buffy/Angel/Spike (Buffy the Vampire Slayer)
Buffy Summers’ love life was complicated, to say the least, especially when it came to her relationships with Angel and Spike. Angel, the mysterious and brooding vampire, was Buffy’s first true love, and their connection was deeply emotional, tied to shared burdens and sacrifice. Fans of the Buffy the Vampire Slayer series were initially torn between the two because of Angel’s tragic backstory and his unwavering love for Buffy. However, when Angel lost his soul and became evil, Buffy’s feelings were challenged, leading to her eventual shift towards Spike, a former enemy with a twisted yet genuine passion for her.
Spike’s evolution as a character also played a significant role in this love triangle. While Angel symbolized Buffy’s first love, Spike was a constant reminder that love could be both painful and redemptive. Spike’s arc was one of the most compelling, as he transitioned from a villain to a character capable of deep love and devotion. This love triangle divided the audience into two camps: one side adhered to the idea of Angel’s eternal love, while others cheered for the fiery and complex relationship between Buffy and Spike. The emotional intensity of both relationships kept fans invested in this love triangle throughout the series.
Pacey/Joey/Dawson (Dawson’s Creek)
In Dawson’s Creek, the love triangle between Joey Potter, Dawson Leery, and Pacey Witter explored the complexities of growing up and navigating romantic feelings. Dawson was Joey’s childhood friend, and their bond was built on shared memories and deep emotional understanding. However, their relationship often felt like it was more about idealized notions of love than true compatibility. Dawson’s overbearing and sometimes selfish nature created friction in their relationship, leaving Joey questioning whether their connection was built to last.
Enter Pacey, the charming and rebellious boy-next-door, who brought excitement and passion into Joey’s life. Pacey was unafraid to show Joey the joy of being spontaneous and carefree, contrasting sharply with Dawson’s more serious demeanor. Fans were divided between the two, with some rooting for the steady, familiar bond between Joey and Dawson, while others saw Pacey as the one who truly challenged Joey to become her best self. The triangle ultimately highlighted how love can evolve as people grow and change, making it one of the most memorable romantic conflicts in teen TV history.
Elena/Damon/Stefan (The Vampire Diaries)
Elena Gilbert’s love triangle with Damon and Stefan Salvatore in The Vampire Diaries captivated fans with its intense emotional stakes and complex dynamics. Stefan, the gentle and self-sacrificing older brother, was Elena’s first love, and their relationship was built on a foundation of trust and shared history. Stefan’s commitment to protecting Elena and keeping her safe was a consistent theme throughout the series, and their bond seemed to represent the ideal of a pure, enduring love.
On the other hand, Damon, the charming, unpredictable younger brother, was more raw and intense in his pursuit of Elena. Initially seen as a villain, Damon’s relationship with Elena shifted over time as his character became more layered and vulnerable. Elena’s attraction to Damon was undeniable, but it was their emotional connection that truly captivated audiences. While Stefan’s love was steady and comforting, Damon’s was passionate and all-consuming, which led to a divided fan base: some believed Stefan was the right choice for Elena, while others argued that Damon’s love, though messy, was the one that truly tested her heart. The tension between these two brothers, both of whom loved Elena in different ways, created an unforgettable love triangle that fans continued to debate long after the series ended.
Chuck/Blair/Dan (Gossip Girl)
The love triangle between Blair Waldorf, Chuck Bass, and Dan Humphrey in Gossip Girl was one of the most tumultuous and emotionally charged relationships in the series. Blair and Chuck’s relationship was a rollercoaster, filled with passion, betrayal, and deep emotional connection. Chuck, the charming and flawed billionaire, was Blair’s counterpart in the world of Upper East Side excess, and their relationship was a mixture of power, control, and undeniable chemistry. Their fiery love and deep bond made them a favorite among fans, even though they were constantly pushed to the edge by their personal struggles and toxic dynamics.
However, Dan Humphrey, the outsider from Brooklyn, provided a stark contrast to Chuck’s dark and seductive nature. Dan’s relationship with Blair was grounded in intellectual connection and genuine affection, which often put him at odds with Chuck’s dramatic and complicated love. Fans were divided between the fiery passion that Chuck and Blair shared and the more stable, albeit less exciting, love that Blair found with Dan. The triangle was a constant theme throughout the show, with fans passionately picking sides, making it one of the most iconic and debated love triangles in teen drama history.
Jane/Rafael/Michael (Jane the Virgin)
In Jane the Virgin, Jane Villanueva found herself caught in an emotional whirlwind between two very different men: Rafael Solano and Michael Cordero. Rafael, the charming and successful businessman, had a complicated past with Jane, especially with their unexpected pregnancy. Their relationship started with passion and uncertainty, making their connection feel fated and intense. Over time, Rafael’s vulnerability and deeper commitment to Jane made fans root for their relationship, despite the rocky beginnings.
On the other hand, Michael, the dependable and loyal detective, was Jane’s high school sweetheart. His steady love for Jane was a constant, and he was always there for her through thick and thin. Michael’s unwavering support made him a beloved character, but his relationship with Jane was also tested by her growing feelings for Rafael. The triangle forced Jane to choose between the comfort of a relationship she knew well and the excitement of a more unpredictable, passionate love with Rafael. Fans were fiercely divided on which man Jane should end up with, making this one of the most heart-wrenching and talked-about love triangles on TV.
Rory/Dean/Jess/Logan (Gilmore Girls)
Gilmore Girls introduced an unforgettable love quadrangle with Rory Gilmore’s complicated feelings for her boyfriends: Dean, Jess, and Logan. Dean was Rory’s first love, and their relationship was innocent and full of youthful charm. Dean’s steady and reliable nature was comforting to Rory, but over time, their differences became apparent, especially as Rory’s ambitions began to take her in a different direction. Jess, on the other hand, was the rebellious bad boy who challenged Rory intellectually and emotionally, pushing her to think beyond the small-town boundaries she had grown up in. Their chemistry was undeniable, but their relationship was often marked by tension and conflict.
Logan, Rory’s college boyfriend, brought an entirely different dynamic to the table. His wealth and social status were in stark contrast to Rory’s humble background, and their love affair was filled with luxury, adventure, and unexpected complications. Each of Rory’s relationships highlighted different sides of her personality and her growth as a young woman. Fans were often split between Dean’s steady love, Jess’s intellectual allure, and Logan’s passionate yet complicated affection, making this love quadrangle one of the most debated and analyzed in TV history.
Ryan/Marissa/Oliver (The O.C.)
In The O.C., the love triangle between Ryan Atwood, Marissa Cooper, and Oliver Trask had fans captivated, especially with Oliver’s obsessive behavior and manipulative tactics. Ryan and Marissa’s relationship was intense and fraught with emotional turmoil, beginning when Ryan, the outsider from Chino, first entered her life. Their bond was formed on mutual understanding and a deep emotional connection, but Marissa’s tendency to act impulsively often led to complications. Ryan was protective of Marissa, and he was always there to support her, despite the difficulties they faced as a couple.
Enter Oliver Trask, a new character who quickly became an obstacle in Ryan and Marissa’s relationship. Oliver’s charm and smooth talk initially made him seem like a worthy love interest for Marissa, but it quickly became clear that he was more dangerous than he appeared. His manipulative nature and obsession with Marissa caused major tension, pushing Ryan and Marissa further apart. While many fans were torn between rooting for Ryan’s protective love and Marissa’s tumultuous connection with Oliver, it was clear that the toxic influence of Oliver was a major catalyst for the drama that unfolded in this love triangle.
Jim/Pam/Karen (The Office)
In The Office, the love triangle between Jim Halpert, Pam Beesly, and Karen Filippelli added a layer of drama and emotional complexity to the series. Jim and Pam were the office’s golden couple, with their connection growing over the seasons, but their relationship was always complicated by Pam’s engagement to Roy. When Jim left for the Stamford branch, he met Karen, who was smart, confident, and much more direct than Pam. Their brief relationship became a point of contention, especially when Jim returned to Scranton and Pam had to deal with her own feelings about Jim’s absence and his new relationship.
The triangle sparked emotional tension, especially as fans were torn between Jim and Pam’s deep connection and Jim’s brief yet passionate time with Karen. Pam’s eventual realization of her love for Jim was a major turning point in the show, but many fans struggled with the idea that Jim’s feelings for Karen were real, even if only temporary. This triangle pushed Jim and Pam’s relationship to the next level, forcing them to confront their feelings and solidify their bond. The love triangle added an unexpected layer of heartache and joy, making it one of the most emotional arcs in The Office.
Archie/Betty/Veronica (Riverdale)
In Riverdale, Archie Andrews’ love life has been a central storyline, especially his complicated relationships with Betty Cooper and Veronica Lodge. Betty represents Archie’s childhood friend and the girl-next-door archetype, embodying loyalty, understanding, and the stability that Archie often seeks amid the chaos of Riverdale. Fans have long debated whether Betty’s supportive and nurturing nature makes her the ideal partner for Archie or if her sometimes obsessive tendencies complicate the relationship.
Veronica, in contrast, brings excitement, sophistication, and a sense of adventure into Archie’s life. Her wealth, confidence, and daring personality present a stark contrast to Betty’s grounded approach, making her a thrilling, albeit sometimes unpredictable, romantic interest. The tension between Archie’s feelings for Betty and Veronica has divided viewers, as some root for the familiarity and reliability of Betty, while others prefer the passionate, high-energy connection Archie shares with Veronica. This love triangle drives much of the show’s drama, keeping fans debating loyalties throughout multiple seasons.
Meredith/Derek/Addison (Grey’s Anatomy)
In Grey’s Anatomy, the love triangle between Meredith Grey, Derek Shepherd, and Addison Montgomery was one of the series’ earliest and most dramatic storylines. Derek and Meredith’s chemistry was undeniable, but their relationship began under complicated circumstances, as Derek was married to Addison. The emotional turmoil of the situation was heightened by the fact that Meredith had no idea about Addison’s existence when she first became involved with Derek. The reveal of Addison’s return to Seattle Grace led to one of the most emotional and heartbreaking moments of the series, as Meredith had to confront her feelings for Derek and the guilt of being the other woman.
Addison’s character added a layer of complexity to this love triangle, as she was a strong, confident woman who was determined to win Derek back. While Meredith and Derek’s connection grew over the seasons, Addison’s role as Derek’s estranged wife brought a sense of tension and unresolved conflict. Fans were divided between supporting Derek and Meredith’s intense but difficult love or rooting for Addison’s efforts to reclaim her marriage. The triangle ultimately shaped many of the characters’ arcs, leading to significant growth and heartache for all involved.
This article originally appeared on Avocadu.