13 Supernatural Shows Where Romance Took a Strange Turn
There is something fascinating about love stories that defy the usual rules, and when the supernatural is involved, the stakes are higher than ever. These series explore relationships that go beyond the ordinary, blending romance with all things strange and unexplainable. From forbidden love between vampires and humans to deep connections with ghosts, the possibilities seem endless. These love stories challenge expectations and take us to places we never imagined.
This post may contain affiliate links, which helps keep this content free. Please read our disclosure for more info.
Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Buffy the Vampire Slayer is one of the most iconic supernatural series, blending horror, action, and romance. The relationship between Buffy and Angel, a vampire with a soul, is central to the show, adding complexity to both their love and the show’s themes of good versus evil. Their love story is filled with obstacles, including Angel’s cursed soul and the tragic separation that comes with it. The series explores how love can exist in the most unlikely and dangerous circumstances, and the deep emotional connection they share leaves a lasting impact on viewers.
Buffy and Angel’s relationship is filled with heartache, passion, and sacrifice. This love story stands out because it challenges the boundaries between human and vampire, blending the supernatural with real human emotions. Over time, Buffy’s romantic relationships evolve, but her bond with Angel remains a cornerstone of the series. The series shows that love is often messy and complicated, even in the supernatural world.
The Vampire Diaries
The Vampire Diaries is a supernatural drama that intertwines love and betrayal across generations of vampires, witches, and humans. The central love triangle between Elena, Stefan, and Damon Salvatore adds layers of intrigue, with both brothers being vampires but having very different personalities and approaches to love. The show explores forbidden love, loyalty, and the consequences of immortal life, making every relationship both thrilling and tragic. Elena’s choice between the two brothers defines much of the series’ drama, with supernatural twists intensifying their emotional journey.
The series delves into the complexities of love between humans and supernatural beings, questioning whether such relationships can survive the test of time and extraordinary circumstances. Each love story in The Vampire Diaries carries its own dark twist, with deep emotional stakes tied to immortality and the dangers of the supernatural world. Whether it is the deep and tragic love of Stefan and Elena or the passionate, reckless bond between Damon and Elena, the show keeps viewers engaged in every supernatural romance. The show is a perfect example of love in a world where time, danger, and betrayal play crucial roles.
Charmed
Charmed focuses on the lives of three sisters who discover they are powerful witches destined to fight evil forces. The show explores the intersection of love and magic as each sister navigates their relationships with both mortals and supernatural beings. Piper’s relationship with Leo, an angel, stands out as the central romance, illustrating how love can transcend even the most formidable obstacles. Their bond is tested time and again by the supernatural threats they face, but their deep connection makes their love story compelling and unique.
Charmed brings together magic, family, and romance, creating a rich tapestry of relationships that evolve throughout the series. The romance between Piper and Leo highlights the conflict of having to balance a normal life with a world of magic and danger. Other romantic relationships in the show also explore similar themes, such as trust, loyalty, and the power of love in the face of dark forces. The show proves that love is not always easy, but it is worth fighting for, even in the world of witches and demons.
True Blood
True Blood takes the concept of supernatural love to new extremes, blending vampires, shapeshifters, and other creatures with human relationships. The main romance between Sookie Stackhouse, a telepathic waitress, and Bill Compton, a vampire, explores the forbidden and dangerous side of love between humans and vampires. Their relationship is complicated by Bill’s dark past and the threats posed by the vampire world. The show thrives on the tension between Sookie’s desire for normalcy and her undeniable attraction to the supernatural.
True Blood’s exploration of love goes beyond the surface, addressing issues of prejudice, power dynamics, and personal sacrifice. The show also delves into the complexities of relationships in the supernatural world, especially in a society where vampires have “come out of the coffin.” As Sookie gets involved with more supernatural beings, her relationships grow even more complicated, leading to heartache and conflict. The supernatural elements amplify the intensity of the love stories, making them more captivating.
Supernatural
Supernatural follows brothers Sam and Dean Winchester as they hunt demons, ghosts, and other creatures. Throughout the series, romantic relationships are a recurring theme, with Sam and Dean both facing the challenges of finding love in their dangerous world. Sam’s relationship with Jessica, followed by his romantic entanglement with other characters, contrasts with Dean’s complex relationship with his love life and commitment. Their love stories are often fleeting due to the nature of their work, but they remain integral to the emotional core of the series.
The show’s unique blend of action, horror, and drama highlights the importance of love and family, even in a world dominated by supernatural threats. Dean’s more cynical view of relationships contrasts with Sam’s desire for a normal life, adding depth to their characters. Their experiences with love are complicated by their lifestyle, but each relationship contributes to their growth as individuals. Supernatural showcases how love can survive in even the darkest worlds, despite the danger and heartbreak that often accompany it.
The Originals
The Originals, a spin-off of The Vampire Diaries, takes the story of the first family of vampires and their complicated romantic entanglements. The show is centered around the Mikaelson family, particularly the love triangle between Klaus, Elijah, and Hayley. Klaus’s tumultuous and toxic relationship with Hayley stands as one of the most powerful romances, as it deals with issues of family loyalty, betrayal, and redemption. Their bond is tested by the supernatural powers around them, but the emotional depth of their love adds layers to the drama.
The Originals offers a fresh perspective on love and relationships within the supernatural world, showing that even the most dangerous and immortal beings can experience heartbreak and passion. Klaus’s love for Hayley is built on complex emotions, from deep affection to raw desire, making it one of the show’s most intriguing plots. The show also explores the impact of family on romantic choices, with the Mikaelson siblings’ relationships often influencing the decisions they make. Love is never easy, but in the supernatural world of The Originals, it is always fierce and unforgettable.
Constantine
Constantine follows the adventures of John Constantine, a demon hunter and occult detective, as he navigates a world filled with supernatural dangers. Although the series primarily focuses on action and the occult, Constantine’s troubled romantic past plays an important role in his character development. His complicated feelings for his former lover, Angela, who is caught up in the supernatural world, showcase the personal cost of being involved in such a dangerous life. Their love story is filled with betrayal, loss, and the constant threat of death, making it one of the more intense romantic arcs.
Constantine’s series delves into the tension between love and duty, with John often having to sacrifice personal relationships for the greater good. His relationships are marred by the supernatural world’s corruption, yet his love for Angela shows his vulnerability. Despite his often cynical outlook on life, Constantine’s romantic entanglements show that even the most hardened characters can long for connection. The series explores how love and sacrifice coexist in a world where the supernatural is an ever-present danger.
Shadowhunters
Shadowhunters brings the world of angels, demons, and humans to life with the story of Clary Fray, a young girl who discovers she is a Shadowhunter, part of a group tasked with protecting the human world from dark forces. Her romance with Jace Wayland, a fellow Shadowhunter, is complicated by their shared history and their connection to a larger war between good and evil. Their love is challenged by family secrets, powerful enemies, and the constant danger surrounding them. Despite all the obstacles, their bond becomes a defining element of the series.
Shadowhunters combines action, magic, and romance in a compelling way, making the relationships feel as intense as the battles between the Shadowhunters and demons. The series explores themes of forbidden love, identity, and destiny, as Clary and Jace struggle to navigate their feelings for one another while saving the world. Their love is tested time and again, proving that true connections can endure even the most dangerous and complicated of supernatural worlds. The chemistry between the two characters makes their love story one of the most captivating parts of the show.
Teen Wolf
Teen Wolf is a supernatural series that blends werewolves, romance, and high school drama. The love story between Scott McCall, a high school student turned werewolf, and Allison Argent, a human with ties to a family of hunters, is central to the series. Their relationship is complicated by the dangers that Scott’s werewolf life brings, as well as the constant threat of supernatural creatures. Despite the odds, their love grows deeper, though not without its share of heartache and sacrifice.
Teen Wolf explores how love can thrive even in the most challenging and supernatural environments. Scott and Allison’s relationship is filled with moments of passion, trust, and loss, highlighting how their love grows in a world that forces them to face impossible choices. Their bond is tested by the supernatural world they inhabit, with both facing life-threatening situations together. Teen Wolf’s romantic arcs offer a thrilling mix of love, loyalty, and danger, making it one of the most memorable supernatural shows in the genre.
Being Human
Being Human focuses on three twenty-something roommates who struggle to live normal lives despite being a ghost, a vampire, and a werewolf. The show takes a unique look at the struggles of love and identity when supernatural forces are involved. The relationship between Aidan, a vampire, and Sally, a ghost, is a central romance, exploring how love can survive death and the challenges that come with it. The series also touches on the complicated romantic life of Josh, the werewolf, as he navigates his transformations and his relationships.
Being Human captures the difficulty of balancing supernatural lives with human emotions. Aidan and Sally’s relationship is one of the most poignant, showing the depth of love even when one of them is no longer alive. The series explores how love can be a source of both salvation and destruction, and it reflects the complexity of human emotions, even in the supernatural world. It is a love story filled with emotional highs and heartbreaking lows.
The Secret Circle
The Secret Circle follows Cassie Blake, a teenage girl who discovers she is part of a powerful witch coven. Throughout the series, Cassie’s love story with Adam Conant, another witch, is central to the plot, though their relationship is complicated by the darker forces surrounding them. The forbidden nature of their love, tied to their powers and the danger it brings, makes it all the more intense. Their relationship is tested by the constant threat of other witches who want to control them.
The Secret Circle delves into the challenges of love in a world of magic, where every romantic choice can have dangerous consequences. Adam and Cassie’s bond grows despite the complications of their powers, showing how love can blossom even under extreme pressure. The series emphasizes the connection between love and power, and how both can be manipulated for good or evil. Their relationship is a central part of the series, illustrating how love can be both a source of strength and vulnerability.
Sleepy Hollow
Sleepy Hollow is a supernatural series based on the classic story of Ichabod Crane and his return to modern-day Sleepy Hollow. Ichabod’s relationship with Abbie Mills, a local police lieutenant, is one of the central romances in the show. The two work together to uncover supernatural mysteries, and their bond grows as they face the dangers of the otherworldly forces threatening their town. Their relationship is defined by mutual respect, trust, and a deep emotional connection that transcends time.
The series explores how love can thrive even in a world filled with dark forces and ancient curses. Ichabod and Abbie’s connection is both powerful and heartwarming, as they fight together against supernatural evil. Their love story is unique because it grows amid the battles they face, making every moment they share feel more meaningful. Sleepy Hollow shows that love can be a source of strength when facing unimaginable forces.
The X-Files
The X-Files is a groundbreaking supernatural series that blends paranormal investigations with personal relationships. The complex relationship between FBI agents Mulder and Scully forms the backbone of the series, with their professional bond slowly evolving into a deep personal connection. Their love story is subtle and slow-burn, often overshadowed by the mysteries they investigate, yet it remains one of the most iconic relationships in television. The paranormal elements of the show only serve to heighten the emotional depth of their connection.
Mulder and Scully’s romance is filled with uncertainty, but it is built on a foundation of trust, respect, and shared experiences. Their love story is a quiet but powerful force that runs through the entire series, providing emotional weight to the supernatural cases they tackle. The slow progression of their relationship against the backdrop of strange events makes their love story even more compelling. The X-Files demonstrates that love can flourish even in the most unusual and extraordinary circumstances.
This article originally appeared on Avocadu.