15 Romantic Comedies That Were Better Than the Critics Said
Romantic comedies often get a bad rap from critics, but many are actually much better than their reviews suggest. While some movies may not win awards, they still capture our hearts in unexpected ways. These films are filled with charm, wit, and unforgettable moments. If you are in the mood for a light-hearted escape, these comedies are worth your time.
This post may contain affiliate links, which helps keep this content free. Please read our disclosure for more info.
The Proposal (2009)
This romantic comedy stars Sandra Bullock and Ryan Reynolds, whose chemistry brings charm to a story that could have been predictable. Bullock plays a tough boss who convinces her assistant to marry her to avoid deportation. Their journey from enemies to lovers is filled with funny moments, sweet gestures, and heartfelt growth. The film may have been criticized for its formulaic plot, but its performances and humor make it stand out.
The film’s success lies in its ability to balance humor with genuine emotion. Reynolds plays the perfect foil to Bullock’s character, creating a dynamic that keeps the audience engaged. The setting in Alaska provides a beautiful backdrop that contrasts with the comedic moments. This film is a feel-good story that will leave you laughing, no matter what the critics say.
13 Going on 30 (2004)
Jennifer Garner shines as a young girl who magically wakes up as a 30-year-old woman, navigating the adult world in a hilarious and heartwarming way. The film may have seemed a bit far-fetched, but its heartfelt message about love and self-discovery resonated with many. Garner’s performance is genuine, and the movie balances humor with emotional depth. The romantic aspect is sweet, but the message of embracing your true self is what truly makes it memorable.
The 80s nostalgia adds a layer of fun, as the film is filled with quirky moments and delightful music from that era. While the critics didn’t always appreciate its whimsical charm, audiences fell in love with the story’s warmth. The combination of fantasy and romance strikes the perfect balance, making it a beloved classic today. Garner’s likable performance elevates the film beyond its initial critical reception.
Crazy, Stupid, Love (2011)
Starring Steve Carell, Ryan Gosling, and Emma Stone, this rom-com explores love in its many forms with humor and sincerity. Carell’s character, who’s recently divorced, seeks help from Gosling’s charming womanizer to regain his confidence. The film skillfully intertwines several storylines, each offering insight into the complexities of relationships. Critics may have seen it as just another romantic comedy, but its depth and clever writing set it apart.
The film’s ensemble cast delivers standout performances, with Stone and Gosling’s chemistry especially noteworthy. While it’s a comedy at heart, the film does not shy away from tackling real relationship issues. It’s a movie that combines laughs with meaningful moments, and its clever twists make it an enjoyable watch. Over time, it has gained a loyal following for its heartfelt and funny take on modern romance.
Notting Hill (1999)
This beloved rom-com starring Julia Roberts and Hugh Grant may have received mixed reviews at first, but it has since become a classic. Grant’s charming, awkward character, paired with Roberts’ charismatic portrayal of a famous actress, creates an unforgettable dynamic. The story, while straightforward, is enriched by the natural chemistry between the leads and the picturesque London setting. Critics who initially dismissed it didn’t see the lasting appeal of its heartfelt simplicity.
The film’s humor comes from its quirky characters and their relatable struggles with love and fame. While the premise is not groundbreaking, it’s the execution that makes it special. The film’s famous line, “I’m just a girl, standing in front of a boy, asking him to love her,” has become iconic, cementing its place in romantic comedy history. It’s a timeless film that continues to capture hearts, even years after its release.
Love, Rosie (2014)
This romantic comedy, based on Cecelia Ahern’s novel, focuses on the long-running friendship and love story between Rosie and Alex. The film jumps through the years, showing how their relationship develops amid missed opportunities and life’s challenges. Critics may have found its structure a bit unconventional, but the emotional depth and humor resonate with audiences. Lily Collins and Sam Claflin’s performances are particularly strong, making the film’s bittersweet moments even more impactful.
What sets Love, Rosie apart is its focus on the complexity of relationships, showing that sometimes love is not as straightforward as it seems. The movie’s charm lies in its realistic portrayal of missed chances, heartbreak, and second chances. Though critics didn’t always praise its pacing, it’s a refreshing take on the romantic comedy genre. The heartwarming ending leaves viewers with a sense of hope, proving that love often comes when you least expect it.
The Wedding Planner (2001)
Jennifer Lopez stars in The Wedding Planner as a successful wedding planner who falls for the groom of one of her clients. The film’s predictable storyline didn’t impress critics, but Lopez’s charm and the undeniable chemistry between her and Matthew McConaughey made it a hit with audiences. The film balances romance, humor, and the beauty of love in a light-hearted way. Despite mixed reviews, it became a favorite for rom-com fans.
The movie’s appeal lies in its charming lead couple, who manage to make even the most cliché moments feel fresh. Lopez’s performance is endearing, and McConaughey brings his usual charisma to the role. The setting of San Francisco adds to the film’s romantic atmosphere, with stunning views and beautiful locations. Even critics who dismissed the film’s predictability couldn’t deny its charm and lasting appeal.
Serendipity (2001)
This film stars John Cusack and Kate Beckinsale as two strangers who meet by chance and form a romantic connection. Despite their immediate chemistry, they part ways, leaving their love story to fate. Critics may have found the film’s reliance on coincidence too much, but its sweet, whimsical nature has made it a holiday classic. The idea of fate guiding two people to each other is a timeless theme, and the film handles it with warmth and humor.
The film’s charm is in its moments of serendipity, showing how life sometimes works in mysterious ways. Cusack and Beckinsale have excellent on-screen chemistry, and their journey to finding each other is filled with heartwarming moments. Although some critics didn’t see the magic in the storyline, audiences loved its idealistic take on love and destiny. The film’s enduring popularity proves that sometimes, the best romances are the ones that feel meant to be.
Sweet Home Alabama (2002)
In Sweet Home Alabama, Reese Witherspoon plays a successful fashion designer who returns to her hometown to finalize her divorce, only to find herself torn between two loves. Critics initially dismissed it as a typical Southern romantic comedy, but the film’s charm and Witherspoon’s performance made it a box-office hit. The movie offers a perfect blend of humor, romance, and heartfelt moments. Witherspoon’s portrayal of a woman who must reconcile her past with her future resonates with many viewers.
The setting of Alabama adds to the film’s charm, with picturesque landscapes and small-town appeal. The supporting cast, including Josh Lucas and Patrick Dempsey, bring depth to the film’s love triangle. While critics may have seen it as formulaic, it still connects with audiences who appreciate its light-hearted yet emotional story. The movie’s lasting popularity proves that a well-executed romantic comedy never goes out of style.
While You Were Sleeping (1995)
This film, starring Sandra Bullock, tells the story of a woman who saves the life of a man she secretly loves and then gets involved with his family while he is in a coma. Critics may have found the plot a bit improbable, but Bullock’s performance and the charming supporting cast make this romantic comedy stand out. The movie is filled with warmth, humor, and a sense of familial love that makes it more than just a typical rom-com.
Bullock’s portrayal of a kind-hearted but lonely woman is heartfelt, and the film’s supporting cast adds layers to the story. The wintery Chicago setting gives the movie a cozy, festive feel, perfect for a romantic comedy. Although it may have been overlooked by some critics, the film continues to be beloved by fans who appreciate its blend of comedy and genuine emotion. It is a movie that shows how love can bloom in unexpected ways.
Definitely, Maybe (2008)
In Definitely, Maybe, Ryan Reynolds plays a father telling his daughter the story of how he met her mother, weaving through his past relationships. The film explores love, relationships, and the paths that lead to finding “the one.” Critics were divided on its unconventional narrative, but the movie’s honest portrayal of relationships and Reynolds’ charm made it a standout. The film is refreshingly different from other romantic comedies, offering a more mature take on love.
The film’s unique structure, which has Reynolds narrating his love life through different perspectives, makes it engaging and full of surprises. The movie balances humor with real emotional moments, especially in the final twist. While some critics found it too confusing, it resonates with audiences who appreciate a deeper look at love and relationships. It is a film that proves romantic comedies don’t always have to follow the traditional formula.
The 40-Year-Old Virgin (2005)
Starring Steve Carell, this comedy takes a unique approach to romance by focusing on a middle-aged man’s awkward journey to losing his virginity. Critics initially questioned the film’s premise, but it quickly became a hit thanks to Carell’s brilliant performance and the film’s humor. The movie blends crude comedy with sincere moments of character growth, making it more than just a laugh-out-loud experience. Carell’s portrayal of the sweet, vulnerable Andy resonates with viewers long after the final scene.
Despite its unconventional story, the film manages to deliver heartfelt moments between characters. The supporting cast, including Paul Rudd and Seth Rogen, adds to the comedic value, making it an ensemble success. While critics initially dismissed it as another raunchy comedy, its charm and emotional depth made it a defining movie in the early 2000s. It’s a romantic comedy that proves awkwardness can lead to meaningful relationships.
My Big Fat Greek Wedding (2002)
This charming rom-com centers around the whirlwind romance between a Greek woman and her non-Greek fiancé, a premise that may have seemed cliché but ended up being a cultural phenomenon. The film’s authenticity, warm humor, and quirky characters drew in audiences, even if critics were initially unsure of its appeal. Nia Vardalos, who also wrote the film, brings her Greek heritage to life in a way that resonates with viewers from all backgrounds. The focus on family dynamics and love across cultures gives the film both heart and humor.
While the critics didn’t always praise its predictable plot, the movie became a massive box-office success. It’s a relatable, feel-good film that tackles love, tradition, and self-identity with humor. The film’s blend of family drama and romance gives it more depth than typical romantic comedies. Over time, it has become a classic in its genre, still cherished by fans for its heartwarming portrayal of love and family.
Runaway Bride (1999)
Julia Roberts and Richard Gere reunite in this rom-com about a woman who has a habit of running away from her weddings. The film’s plot, while familiar, delivers charming moments with its likable leads and playful energy. Critics initially panned it for being too similar to Pretty Woman, but the chemistry between Roberts and Gere is undeniable. The film offers both humor and heart, showcasing the transformation of a woman who must face her fears and learn to embrace love.
The film’s charm comes from its relatable themes of commitment, self-discovery, and love. The picturesque small-town setting enhances the film’s romantic feel, with breathtaking visuals and a sweet, uplifting conclusion. Despite the critics’ lukewarm reception, it remains a favorite for those looking for a lighthearted escape. The pairing of Roberts and Gere is a classic rom-com duo that continues to captivate viewers.
Hitch (2005)
Will Smith plays a smooth-talking dating coach who helps men navigate the complexities of love in this fun and breezy rom-com. The film’s premise might have seemed predictable, but Smith’s charismatic performance elevates it to something more memorable. His chemistry with Eva Mendes, who plays a journalist investigating his coaching methods, adds a layer of warmth to the story. Though the critics found the film formulaic, its charm and humor made it a hit with audiences.
Smith’s ability to balance humor with sincerity gives the film heart, while Mendes brings an interesting dynamic as his love interest. The film’s central theme is about being true to yourself in relationships, which resonates with viewers seeking more than just surface-level comedy. Even with some criticism for its predictable plot, Hitch remains a beloved classic in the rom-com genre. It’s a perfect blend of humor, romance, and a touch of wisdom.
Just Go with It (2011)
Starring Adam Sandler and Jennifer Aniston, Just Go with It tells the story of a man who enlists his assistant to pretend to be his ex-wife in order to impress his love interest. Critics weren’t overly kind to the film, but Sandler’s comedic timing and the chemistry between him and Aniston kept audiences engaged. The film is a blend of outrageous comedy and heartfelt moments, with some surprising emotional depth for a rom-com. Aniston’s performance adds a layer of sweetness, making it more than just a typical Sandler comedy.
While the plot may seem outlandish, the film’s humor, combined with its light-hearted romance, creates a fun experience. The Hawaiian setting provides a beautiful backdrop, adding to the film’s vibrant energy. Despite the mixed reviews, Just Go with It remains a guilty pleasure for many, thanks to its charm and light-hearted approach to romance. It’s a film that will keep you laughing, while also reminding you of the unexpected twists love can take.
This article originally appeared on Avocadu.