13 Retired American Girl Outfits and Sets That People Still Chase

American Girl dolls have a rich history of iconic outfits and accessories that have captured the hearts of collectors. Over the years, many of these retired pieces have become highly sought after. While some are rare, others hold sentimental value, making them even more cherished. If you’ve ever wondered about the most desirable sets, you’re in the right place.

This post may contain affiliate links, which helps keep this content free. Please read our disclosure for more info.

Samantha’s Bathing Costume

Samantha Parkington’s Bathing Costume was released in the mid-1990s and was part of her early collection. The set includes a period-inspired bathing dress, a cap, and matching accessories that reflect the Victorian era. Retired in 2005, it now sells for around $80 to $180, depending on the condition and completeness of the set. This outfit is highly sought after because it was one of the first iconic outfits released for Samantha, a character who continues to hold a special place in the hearts of collectors.

The rarity of this set adds to its appeal, as it was never reissued in the BeForever collection. Many fans chase this piece for its nostalgic value and its connection to Samantha’s early years. The vibrant colors and historical accuracy make it an excellent addition to a collection. Finding the complete set in good condition makes it a real treasure for collectors, often increasing its value.

Molly’s Tennis Outfit

Molly McIntire’s Tennis Outfit, released in the late 1990s, includes a tennis dress, socks, shoes, and a miniature racquet. Retired in 2007, this outfit is valued at $50 to $120 in resale markets. The sporty look is a unique addition to Molly’s collection, representing her active lifestyle during World War II. Fans appreciate this set because it highlights Molly’s interest in sports, which sets her apart from other American Girl characters.

Collectors seek this outfit for its historical significance and the connection to the active, young Molly character. It also stands out due to the miniature racquet and socks, which make it a fun addition to displays. A set in original condition, especially with the racquet, can demand higher prices. Its rarity and sporty design make it a favorite for collectors.

Josefina’s Summer Riding Outfit

Released in the late 1990s, Josefina Montoya’s Summer Riding Outfit includes tall boots, a dress, and a matching hat. Retired in 2009, this set now typically sells for $80 to $150. This outfit is popular among collectors because it reflects Josefina’s life on a ranch in New Mexico, which is an important aspect of her historical background. The combination of rustic accessories and a detailed design makes it highly desirable.

Collectors chase this outfit for its authenticity and historical accuracy. The tall boots and dress give it a unique, detailed look that is harder to find in many other American Girl outfits. The connection to Josefina’s character and the rustic theme add to its appeal, especially for fans of her collection. It remains one of the most sought-after outfits in her historical wardrobe.

Kit’s Party Treats Set

Kit Kittredge’s Party Treats Set, released in the early 2000s, includes an outfit and themed accessories related to a party scene. Retired in 2010, this set is valued at $100 to $200 depending on condition. It stands out due to its connection to Kit’s story during the Great Depression, showcasing the joy of community and simple pleasures. The set includes small props, such as treats, that make it even more collectible.

Collectors appreciate this set because it offers more than just clothing—it also includes accessories that enrich the storytelling experience. The Great Depression-era theme gives it historical value and connects it to Kit’s storyline. The uniqueness of the set and its detailed accessories make it a must-have for fans of Kit’s collection. The rarity of complete sets further increases its appeal.

Kirsten’s Winter Outfit

Kirsten Larson’s Winter Outfit, which includes a skirt, blouse, and wool accessories, was part of her wardrobe in the 1990s. Retired in 2011, it is now valued at $90 to $180. This outfit is beloved by collectors because it highlights Kirsten’s pioneer life and fits the historical context of her character’s story. The winter theme makes it an ideal piece for collectors who enjoy displaying dolls in seasonal settings.

This set is especially popular due to its authenticity in representing life as a Swedish immigrant in the 1850s. The quality materials and simple, rustic design make it a standout in Kirsten’s wardrobe. Collectors chase this set for both its historical accuracy and its timeless design. The rarity of the set in pristine condition makes it even more desirable.

Felicity’s Town Fair Outfit

Felicity Merriman’s Town Fair Outfit was part of a limited edition series in the 1990s. It includes a colonial dress and matching accessories, representing the lively town fair atmosphere of the colonial era. Retired in 2013, it now sells for $70 to $150. This outfit is popular among collectors because it captures the spirit of Felicity’s world and provides a colorful, festive look for displays.

The outfit’s historical accuracy and festive nature make it a standout piece in Felicity’s collection. The colonial fair theme is unique, offering a refreshing alternative to the more formal dresses in her wardrobe. Fans of Felicity’s story enjoy adding this fun, bright outfit to their collections. The limited edition status further contributes to its high demand among collectors.

Addy’s Stilting Outfit

Addy Walker’s Stilting Outfit, released in the late 1990s, includes period-specific play props like stilts, which were common childhood toys during Addy’s time. Retired in 2012, it is valued at $60 to $130. Collectors seek this set because of the unique props included, which set it apart from other historical outfits. The stilts offer a playful, interactive element that’s not typically seen in many other American Girl outfits.

The rarity of this set and the inclusion of fun, interactive accessories make it highly desirable. Fans of Addy’s character, who appreciate the historical accuracy of her collection, enjoy displaying this outfit. The uniqueness of the stilts and the fact that they were never reissued in other collections increases its appeal. The outfit’s playful nature adds a whimsical touch to Addy’s otherwise serious story.

Samantha’s Flower-Picking Set

Samantha Parkington’s Flower-Picking Set was released in the 2000s and includes a floral dress, matching hat, and accessories. Retired in 2009, it is valued at $50 to $120. This set is beloved by collectors for its simple, spring-themed design, perfect for outdoor or garden displays. The bright floral design and the peaceful activity of flower-picking tie it beautifully to Samantha’s character and her childhood.

Collectors enjoy this outfit because of its versatility and seasonal appeal. The vibrant flowers and soft fabric make it a lovely piece to mix and match with other outfits. Its connection to a quiet, serene moment in Samantha’s life adds to its charm. Fans of Samantha’s story often want this set to complete their collection of her seasonal outfits.

Julie’s Dance Set

Julie Albright’s Dance Set, released in the early 2010s, includes a brightly patterned dress and matching accessories, perfect for a dance recital. Retired in 2015, it is typically valued at $40 to $80. This set captures Julie’s connection to the early 1970s and her love for dance. The outfit’s energetic vibe and colorful design make it a fun and lively addition to Julie’s wardrobe.

Collectors are drawn to this set because it represents the free-spirited, cultural movement of the 1970s. The lively design and dance theme make it a standout piece for those who enjoy adding variety to their doll collections. The vibrant patterns and the cultural connection to Julie’s story make this outfit particularly appealing. Its relatively low price point also makes it an accessible collectible for fans of Julie.

Bitty Twins Swimsuit Set

The Bitty Twins Swimsuit Set, released as part of the Bitty Twins line, was retired when the line shifted to a new format. Retired in 2014, this outfit typically sells for $15 to $35. Despite the smaller following for Bitty Twins, this swimsuit set remains a favorite for collectors of the smaller dolls. The bright, playful design adds a fun and colorful touch to any collection.

Collectors often appreciate this set for its cheerful look and its connection to the earlier Bitty Twins dolls. Its casual, beach-ready theme makes it a versatile outfit for both collectors and children. While it is more affordable compared to other retired outfits, its value increases as Bitty Twins items become harder to find. The simplicity of the swimsuit set makes it a great complement to any collection.

Classic White Nightgown

The classic white nightgown has been a staple in early American Girl collections, particularly as a bedtime piece. Retired in 2008, it is typically valued at $30 to $60. This outfit is beloved by collectors because of its timeless design and its simplicity. The nightgown is often used in sleep-themed displays or for dolls that have a vintage bedtime look.

The nightgown’s charm lies in its understated elegance. Its plain white fabric and lace details make it a versatile piece that can fit with many different American Girl dolls. Fans of vintage American Girl dolls appreciate its simplicity, as it’s a representation of the peaceful, quieter moments in doll life. The low price point makes it an accessible collectible, but it remains valuable due to its historical importance.

Vintage Track Suit or Velour Sweat Suit

The Vintage Track Suit, released in the early 2000s, is a casual sporty outfit valued at $15 to $40. Retired in 2003, this outfit is a favorite for those who prefer casual, everyday styles over formal dresses. The warm-up suit works well in a display focused on modern or casual doll themes. Its playful design and activewear style make it a desirable set for collectors.

Collectors enjoy the track suit for its simplicity and unique contrast to other, more formal pieces in American Girl’s wardrobe. The outfit’s vintage look and sporty vibe offer a refreshing change of pace. The accessibility of the set, along with its potential to pair with other casual pieces, adds to its appeal. For those who appreciate variety in their collections, this track suit is a fun addition.

Pleasant Company Jumper Outfit

The classic Pleasant Company jumper outfits, released in the 1990s, are now valued at $50 to $100. Retired in 2001, these early pieces are highly prized because they represent the earliest designs from American Girl’s initial years. Collectors appreciate these outfits for their vintage charm and the connection to the brand’s history. The simplicity of the outfit makes it perfect for casual doll displays.

These jumpers have a simple yet beautiful design that appeals to fans of older American Girl dolls. The rarity of these early pieces adds to their value, and they are often sought by those who want to complete a vintage collection. The outfit’s understated style makes it perfect for both casual and historical-themed displays. Fans of the Pleasant Company era often look for these items to reflect the brand’s original spirit.

This article originally appeared on Avocadu.