12 Rare McDonald’s and Fast-Food Halloween Collectibles From the 80s and 90s

Halloween and fast food once made a surprisingly fun pair. During the 80s and 90s, McDonald’s and other chains handed out toys, buckets, and figures that became instant collector favorites. From the famous pumpkin pails to spooky McNugget Buddies, these items bring back the joy of childhood Halloween nights.

This post may contain affiliate links, which helps keep this content free. Please read our disclosure for more info.

Vintage 1986 McDonald’s Halloween Trick-or-Treat Pumpkin Bucket

This orange pumpkin pail was part of McDonald’s first Halloween set in 1986, and it quickly became a classic. Kids could fill it with fries or candy, then reuse it for trick-or-treating. Its cheerful jack-o’-lantern grin and bright color made it instantly recognizable. For many families, these buckets marked the start of a fall tradition that returned year after year.

The durable plastic made it ideal for playtime, and it often doubled as a toy bin or lunch container. Collectors now love the first-run versions that still have their original lids and stickers. While McDonald’s has reissued newer versions, the original 1986 pails remain the most sought-after. They perfectly capture the fun, simple spirit of a 1980s Halloween.

Vintage 1986 McDonald’s Halloween Bucket (Green Witch)

The green witch bucket brought a playful twist to the original pumpkin design. With her pointy hat and big smile, she stood out as the “spooky” option in McDonald’s first Halloween trio. Parents liked that the bucket was safe, lightweight, and reusable. Kids loved that it made their Happy Meal feel like part of the holiday.

Over time, this witch design became harder to find compared to the orange pumpkin. The vivid green hue sometimes faded, making well-preserved pieces even more collectible today. Many fans remember this bucket sitting by the front door on Halloween night. It’s one of those nostalgic items that feels like pure childhood magic.

Vintage 1986 McBoo Halloween Pail

McBoo was the ghost version of McDonald’s 1986 Halloween pails, complete with a smiling face and white plastic finish. It was cute rather than scary, which made it a hit with younger kids. The bucket tied into McDonald’s friendly Halloween branding, keeping the theme fun and lighthearted. Many kids used it as their candy container for years after.

Collectors today enjoy finding the original ghost pails with their lids intact. The McBoo name appears molded into the plastic, giving it a signature touch that’s easy to spot. Some even came with glow-in-the-dark paint, which added to their charm. These pails remain one of the most recognizable McDonald’s collectibles from the decade.

1992 McDonald’s Happy Meal Halloween McNugget Buddy “Witchie”

In 1992, McDonald’s added a new twist with the Halloween McNugget Buddies, and “Witchie” quickly became a fan favorite. This tiny figure featured a purple witch hat and cape that fit over a smiling Chicken McNugget body. It was silly, playful, and exactly what kids loved about McDonald’s toys. The interchangeable costumes encouraged collecting all the designs.

Over time, “Witchie” gained cult status among fans of 90s Happy Meal toys. Her design perfectly balanced spooky and cute, making her an essential piece for Halloween collectors. Loose figures are still common, but complete sets in good condition can fetch decent prices. She remains one of the most memorable McNugget Buddies ever made.

1998 McDonald’s Grimace Pumpkin Mask Candy Dispenser

By the late 90s, McDonald’s brought back the Halloween fun with themed candy containers like the Grimace pumpkin dispenser. This toy showed Grimace wearing a jack-o’-lantern mask, combining humor and nostalgia in one piece. Kids could open it up and fill it with small treats or candy. It was one of the last Halloween promos before McDonald’s shifted toward movie tie-ins.

Collectors appreciate this toy for its quirky design and bright colors. The pumpkin mask fits over Grimace’s face like a lid, and the interior storage adds extra novelty. While it wasn’t as widely released as earlier items, it still represents the charm of late-90s McDonald’s collectibles. Many see it as a fitting farewell to the brand’s Halloween golden years.

“Skull” McNugget Buddy Halloween 1998

The skull-costumed McNugget Buddy appeared in later Halloween waves and stood out for its fun take on spooky design. It featured a glow-in-the-dark skull mask that snapped over the nugget’s smiling face. The playful mix of fright and humor kept it from feeling too scary for kids. Fans loved the little details, like the printed bones on its outfit.

This version often tops collector wish lists due to its limited production and unique styling. Its glow effect makes it a standout display piece in any retro collection. Many fans recall trading these at school or using them as desk decorations. Decades later, the skull McNugget Buddy still makes collectors smile.

1996 McDonald’s Halloween Happy Meal Box

Before the toys even came out, the box set the scene. The 1996 Halloween Happy Meal box featured bright orange and purple artwork with McDonaldland characters in costume. Kids often cut out the masks or games printed on the sides. The box turned an ordinary meal into a full Halloween experience.

These boxes rarely survived since most kids played with or recycled them. That makes intact ones especially collectible today. Some featured hidden jokes, riddles, or connect-the-dots activities. They remind people that McDonald’s once put real thought into making every detail part of the fun.

The Simpsons Burger King Spooky Light-Up Toy (Halloween)

Burger King joined the Halloween fun with light-up toys featuring The Simpsons. Each one had a glowing base that made the characters appear haunted or electric. Kids could collect multiple designs, including Homer, Bart, and Lisa in costume. The bright light and familiar faces made these toys instant hits.

Collectors now love these for their fun mix of pop culture and Halloween flair. They show how Burger King competed with McDonald’s in creative ways. The glow effect still works on some sets, which makes them even more special. For 90s fans, they’re a perfect piece of Halloween nostalgia.

Burger King “Toonsylvania” Halloween Figure (1990s)

Burger King teamed up with DreamWorks to promote Toonsylvania, a cartoon full of quirky monsters. The figures included characters like Dr. Vic Frankenstein and Igor in silly poses. They blended mild horror with Saturday-morning humor, making them a hit with kids. Each one came in a small plastic bag, often paired with stickers or mini comics.

Collectors appreciate how this line captured the tone of 90s animation and Halloween fun. They’re harder to find today, especially with their packaging intact. Many fans remember these as one of Burger King’s most creative promotions. The mix of monsters and humor made them stand out from typical fast-food toys.

1986 McGoblin Boo Bucket

Alongside McBoo and the pumpkin pail, McDonald’s released a green McGoblin bucket. This version featured a mischievous goblin face that looked ready for Halloween night. It was playful rather than creepy, which made it appealing to younger kids. Each pail came with a snap-on lid for storing treats.

The McGoblin design has become one of the hardest to track down. Collectors often note small variations in face design between early runs. The bucket’s distinctive color makes it a great display piece in vintage collections. It completes the original 1986 trio that started McDonald’s long Halloween legacy.

McDonald’s Ceramic Jack-o’-Lanterns (1990s)

In the 1990s, McDonald’s released ceramic jack-o’-lanterns through select promotions. These small decorations were sturdier than the usual toys and often used as table accents or candle holders. Their simple, smiling faces carried the same cheerful style as the plastic buckets. Fans loved that McDonald’s made something reusable for the holiday.

Because they were breakable, many didn’t survive the years, making them harder to find now. Collectors who locate them with the McDonald’s logo intact consider them lucky finds. The ceramics represented a brief moment when the company leaned into collectible décor rather than toys. They still bring a nostalgic glow to any Halloween display.

Grimace-Themed Saxophone Halloween Variant (1990s)

Among McDonald’s smaller toy lines, a Halloween Grimace figure stood out for his silly costume and saxophone accessory. He often appeared wearing a mask or cape, adding a festive touch to the purple mascot. The toy was bright, clunky, and full of character—exactly the kind of oddball design that made 90s fast-food toys memorable.

Collectors view this as one of the stranger yet charming McDonald’s Halloween pieces. It reflects a time when the brand didn’t take itself too seriously. The mix of music and monsters gave it a playful, offbeat feel. For fans of McDonaldland characters, it’s a fun reminder of the brand’s creative golden age.

This article originally appeared on Avocadu.