13 Mystery Movies That Flew Under the Radar

In the world of film, mystery movies can sometimes get overshadowed by the bigger blockbusters. However, some of the most intriguing and thought-provoking films remain hidden in the shadows. These lesser-known mysteries are packed with suspense and twists you may not see coming. If you enjoy a good story that keeps you on the edge of your seat, these films are worth discovering. Prepare to uncover some hidden treasures.

This post may contain affiliate links, which helps keep this content free. Please read our disclosure for more info.

Forgotten (2017)

This South Korean film begins when Jin-seok’s older brother Yoo-seok returns home after being abducted for nineteen days and seems to have no memory of what happened. The setting is a new house, a locked room that the family is told not to enter, and a nagging sense that everything is wrong. What follows is a twisting narrative that shifts timelines and identities, testing how much the viewer can trust what they are seeing. The film’s willingness to move between time frames and realities makes it memorable and unsettling.

The production was helmed by director Jang Hang-jun and it is listed as a mystery thriller. Though it did not dominate global headlines, it has gathered a cult following for its uneasy atmosphere and unexpected revelations. Watching with a sharp eye pays off because small details early on tie back to major shifts later. For anyone who enjoys puzzle-style mystery films, this one has enough layers to keep you engaged.

The Invisible Guest (2016)

In this Spanish-language thriller, a young successful businessman wakes up next to the dead body of his lover in a locked hotel room and must explain how he got there. The plot unfolds in real time over a few hours as he works with a top lawyer to piece together the truth and clear his name. The film is tightly structured, with twists that force you to question who is telling the truth and what really happened. Critics praised the clever setup and the fact that the story refuses to let you relax.

While the film has achieved a strong reputation in some circles, it remains under-seen in many global markets. The dialogue and pacing reward focused viewing rather than passive watching. For fans of closed-room mysteries or courtroom-adjacent thrillers, this one delivers. It is smart, subtle, and keeps you guessing until the very end.

Infiesto (2023)

Set in a rural Spanish village in March 2020 during the early days of the pandemic, this film follows two inspectors investigating the disappearance of a woman in a remote community. What appears as a standard missing person case slowly reveals links to cult behavior, abandoned mines, and strange local legends. The setting feels quiet and off the beaten path, which helps the creeping tension build steadily.

The film was shot in locations including Asturias and Galicia and features local landscapes that reinforce the sense of isolation. It might not have reached large audiences outside Spanish-speaking markets but is worth the effort if you are looking for a mystery that uses atmosphere and setting as effectively as plot. The slow-burn unfolding of events makes it ideal for a focused weekend viewing.

The Silence of the Marsh (2019)

This Spanish mystery thriller revolves around a crime-novelist turned journalist whose investigations blur into the crimes he writes about. Set in Valencia, the story explores how the writer uses his position to commit crimes while covering them, creating a layered tension of guilt, storytelling, and self-incrimination. The production makes clever use of local architecture and the setting’s oppressive heat to keep the tension high.

Though it premiered at the Seville European Film Festival and later appeared on Netflix, it has largely flown under mainstream attention. The dialogue and pacing reward focused viewing rather than passive watching. For fans of mysteries where the protagonist is not clearly heroic and the setting plays an active role in the story, this one offers something different.

I Am All Girls (2021)

This South African-made film deals with the grim reality of sex-trafficking syndicates in the apartheid and post-apartheid eras, with a detective duo hunting down perpetrators while a killer targets the syndicate members one by one. The narrative is based on true events though fictionalized for cinematic impact. The global reach of the story is broad, and the film was, at one point, among the world’s Top 10 on Netflix.

The film’s strength lies in its commitment to social themes and its willingness to hold the viewer’s attention through complex, morally ambiguous characters. It may not feel like a classic whodunit, but if you focus on motive, opportunity, and systemic corruption as pieces of the puzzle, it qualifies as a mystery worth discussing. For anyone interested in mysteries with global settings and serious subject matter, this one stands out.

The Body (2012)

In this Spanish film, a detective investigates the disappearance of a woman’s body from a morgue, only to uncover an unsettling conspiracy. The narrative moves between tense flashbacks and current-day investigations, keeping viewers on edge. As the film progresses, secrets are revealed, and the detective starts to question the very nature of the case. The atmosphere is moody, and the film excels in maintaining suspense throughout.

The intricate plot and unpredictable twists make it a standout mystery. The film’s setting is dark and atmospheric, reinforcing its tension-filled moments. Fans of cerebral, twist-heavy thrillers will appreciate the steady buildup and unexpected conclusions. It has earned a cult following, though it remains underappreciated compared to other mystery thrillers.

The Night Eats the World (2018)

In this French film, a man wakes up to find that a zombie apocalypse has overtaken Paris while he was asleep. Trapped in an apartment, he must outsmart the hordes outside and survive in an isolated world. Although the premise may seem standard, the movie focuses more on psychological horror than action, making it an intriguing mystery.

The film’s focus on isolation and the psychological toll of being alone with a threat makes it stand out from traditional zombie films. Its subtle pacing, combined with a haunting atmosphere, pulls viewers into the story. The mystery lies not just in the survival elements but in the questions of what happens to the human psyche in such extreme isolation. For fans of slow-burning tension and character-driven mysteries, this one is worth a watch.

The Gift (2015)

This psychological thriller features a married couple whose life takes a turn when an old acquaintance from the husband’s past reappears with unsettling intentions. The film masterfully builds tension, with every scene giving subtle clues to the growing mystery. As the past resurfaces, dark secrets about the husband’s past begin to unravel.

Joel Edgerton, who both wrote and directed the film, crafts a chilling atmosphere that keeps the viewer questioning what’s truly happening. The tension is palpable, and the film offers a few unexpected turns that will leave you on the edge of your seat. The small, intimate setting of the home and the calm but unnerving interactions between characters create a potent atmosphere. For those who appreciate slow-burning suspense, this film will keep you intrigued until the last reveal.

Coherence (2013)

This low-budget sci-fi thriller follows a group of friends at a dinner party when a comet passes overhead, causing strange and inexplicable occurrences. The film plays with parallel realities, creating a complex mystery around the events that unfold. As the guests begin to notice that things aren’t as they seem, the tension ramps up with each passing minute.

With its tight, cerebral plot, this film explores the concept of reality versus perception, and the mystery is woven through every conversation and event. The film makes the most of its limited setting, relying on psychological tension and clever dialogue to keep viewers hooked. The low-budget nature of the film adds to its appeal, proving that a strong concept and tight execution can create a memorable experience. For those who enjoy movies that challenge the mind and leave you questioning everything, Coherence offers a thrilling ride.

A Simple Favor (2018)

This stylish mystery-thriller stars Anna Kendrick and Blake Lively, following a mommy blogger who becomes involved in a complicated and dangerous investigation after her friend goes missing. The film balances dark humor with mystery, and its twists keep you on your toes. As the plot develops, layers of deceit, secrets, and hidden agendas slowly surface.

The performances in this film elevate its mystery elements, with Blake Lively’s portrayal of a charismatic yet mysterious character adding depth. The film’s pace keeps the tension high, and the unexpected revelations are perfectly timed. A Simple Favor takes a familiar genre and adds intrigue with its sharp script and unpredictable storyline. For those who enjoy stylish thrillers with a blend of humor and suspense, this one is a great choice.

Hush (2016)

This home-invasion thriller stands out due to its simple yet highly effective premise where a deaf woman is stalked by a masked killer in her isolated house. The film explores both the horror of the situation and the resourcefulness of the protagonist, who must outsmart her pursuer. What makes this film truly unique is its focus on silence, which adds to the tension and makes every noise or movement significant.

The suspense in Hush is amplified by its minimalist approach, where the lack of sound is just as important as the action. With no distractions from elaborate subplots, the film immerses you entirely in the tense, nerve-wracking chase between the woman and the killer. It’s a highly effective thriller that taps into primal fears, making it a hidden gem for horror and mystery fans alike.

The Invitation (2015)

This psychological thriller revolves around a dinner party where the protagonist begins to suspect that something sinister is happening among the guests. The slow-building tension and unsettling interactions make this a unique entry in the mystery genre. The film plays with paranoia and mistrust, leading the audience to question the motivations of the characters.

The minimalist setting, combined with the claustrophobic atmosphere, adds to the growing sense of dread. As the mystery unfolds, the film taps into deeper themes of grief and personal trauma. The Invitation stands out for its subtle approach to suspense, offering viewers a mystery that grows more disturbing the longer you think about it. Fans of suspense and psychological tension will find this film to be an intriguing, unnerving experience.

The Vanishing (2018)

This remake of the 1988 Dutch film The Vanishing tells the true story of a man’s obsession with solving the disappearance of his girlfriend while on a secluded road trip. The film dives deep into themes of obsession and the lengths one man is willing to go to find the truth. What starts as a straightforward mystery soon becomes a chilling exploration of guilt and obsession.

The slow pacing of the film builds a tension that grips the viewer, and the gradual revelation of the dark truths behind the disappearance adds to the mounting suspense. The film is a deep dive into the human psyche, showing the destructive effects of a relentless pursuit for answers. For fans of psychological mysteries with a touch of true-crime edge, this one delivers an eerie, captivating experience.

This article originally appeared on Avocadu.