11 Holiday Cookie Cutters That Have Become Collectible

Holiday baking often begins with a handful of classic cookie cutters that never seem to fade from memory. Many older designs show simple shapes that feel warm and inviting. Collectors look for cutters that reflect seasonal themes or handmade charm. Some pieces carry stories tied to family baking traditions. So join in and learn what makes these cutters stand out.

This post may contain affiliate links, which helps keep this content free. Please read our disclosure for more info.

Aunt Chick’s Merry Xmas Plastic Cutter Set

The Merry Xmas set first appeared in the late 1940s under the well-known Aunt Chick’s brand. Many collectors look for this set because of its bright red plastic and charming vintage shapes. The set usually includes designs such as Santa, a tree, a star, and a stocking. Values tend to sit around US $20 to US $30 depending on condition. Sets with recipe inserts often sell on the higher end.

Another detail that adds to its appeal is the durability of the original material. Owners frequently stored these cutters for decades, making complete sets increasingly scarce. The rounded edges and mid-century style reflect the baking traditions of that era. Collectors enjoy finding versions still bright in color without cracks. Clean examples remain the most desirable.

Wilton Metal Holiday Cutter Set from the 1980s or 1990s

This Wilton set arrived during the late twentieth century and featured familiar shapes such as stars, bells, trees, and snowmen. Wilton often made metal cutters, though holiday sets like these became favorites due to their simplicity. Collectors like them because metal cutters from this period frequently show wear, making cleaner pieces more valuable. Prices often fall between US $10 and US $20. Sets stored well over time hold stronger appeal.

Another point of interest is Wilton’s long history in baking products. Their metal cutters are usually sturdy, yet they still warp if used heavily. Collectors look for pieces without rust and with edges that remain smooth. Sets that include a full assortment draw more attention. Many people appreciate their nostalgic value.

Wear-Ever Aluminum Holiday Cutter Lot from the 1950s

This Wear-Ever assortment dates back to the 1950s and includes seasonal shapes made from lightweight aluminum. Many collectors enjoy Wear-Ever products because they represent a strong era of American kitchenware. Sets often include bells, trees, stars, and gingerbread figures. Values commonly fall between US $20 and US $30. Lots containing multiple shapes tend to have higher appeal.

One detail collectors appreciate is the longevity of aluminum from this period. Many pieces remain usable even after decades of storage. Slight dents are common, yet well-kept pieces show their age beautifully. Mixed sets provide variety that collectors enjoy. Full lots with minimal wear are considered the best finds.

Ekco Six-Piece Metal Christmas Cutter Set from 1997

This Ekco set, released in 1997, includes shapes such as snowflakes, candy canes, holly leaves, and stars. Its collectible nature stems from being part of the later era of widely produced metal cutters before plastic sets became common. Values usually range from US $15 to US $20 when packaging remains intact. Collectors appreciate the crisp edges of Ekco cutters. New-old-stock pieces hold the greatest interest.

The appeal grows when a set includes original packaging. Condition plays a major role because metal edges dull over time. Many owners stored these cutters well, making clean examples easier to find. A complete set presents a nice snapshot of holiday baking in the 1990s. Collectors enjoy the charm of this era’s simple designs.

Mirro Metal Christmas Cutter Set from the 1950s

Mirro created several metal cutter sets in the 1950s, and their holiday shapes remain favorites among collectors. Many appreciate Mirro for its long tradition of strong metal bakeware. These cutters often feature bells, trees, snowmen, and other familiar shapes. Values typically land around US $25. Rust-free examples are the most desirable.

Collectors enjoy Mirro cutters because many still hold their original shine. Some shapes were produced in lower numbers, making them harder to find. Clean examples often show careful storage by previous owners. Slight surface wear is normal yet acceptable. Sets with multiple holiday shapes gain strong interest.

Aunt Chick’s Jolly Days Holiday Cutter Set

This Jolly Days set arrived in the 1950s and brought a different combination of shapes from the same brand. It became collectible because each piece carries the distinctive mid-century look that Aunt Chick’s was known for. Many buyers enjoy the nostalgic style that mirrors holiday baking memories from that period. The typical value ranges from US $25 to US $35. Good condition pieces remain the most sought after.

Another reason it appeals to collectors is the way the designs helped shape cookie traditions of the time. Some shapes were produced in smaller numbers, which increases interest today. Intact coloring and crisp edges make any example more attractive. Sets with their original storage box gain added attention. Collectors appreciate the blend of rarity and charm.

Aluminum Handle-Style Holiday Cutters from the 1950s

These handle-style cutters from the 1950s include bells, gingerbread figures, stars, and trees. Their small raised handles made them easier to grip, which gave them a unique place in mid-century kitchenware. Collectors enjoy these because they represent a transitional design in cookie-cutter history. A typical lot sells for US $22 to US $28. Sets with sturdy handles attract the most attention.

Another appealing trait is the shape consistency these cutters maintain. Many retain crisp edges that still function well today. Aluminum construction allowed them to resist rust better than other metals. Light dents are common yet rarely lessen value. Collectors enjoy the charm of their classic look.

Tupperware Nine-Piece Holiday Cutter Set

This nine-piece Tupperware set brings a slightly expanded variety compared to the more common eight-piece version. Collectors enjoy identifying the small design differences between sets from different years. Values generally fall around US $20. Clean edges and bright coloring help strengthen the set’s appeal. Complete versions remain the most desirable.

The added variety makes these sets more interesting to collectors. Some shapes are seen less often, which increases interest. Buyers check for fading or discoloration that sometimes affects vintage plastic. Pieces that remain vibrant after decades of storage tend to sell more quickly. Sets with all nine cutters feel more complete and satisfying.

Hallmark Tin Holiday Cookie Cutter Set

This Hallmark tin set from the 1980s features holiday shapes packaged in a decorative storage tin. Many collectors appreciate Hallmark items because the brand consistently released seasonal goods with charming artwork. The cutters were often shaped like wreaths, bells, Santas, and snowflakes. Values usually sit around US $15 to US $25 depending on condition. Tins with original lids and bright graphics draw stronger interest.

What gives this set additional appeal is the connection many buyers have to Hallmark’s holiday products. Families often saved these tins as keepsakes, making well-kept sets more exciting to find. Clean metal cutters inside the tin add to value. Sets kept free of rust sell the fastest. Collectors enjoy the nostalgic presentation of tin packaging.

Martha Stewart Everyday Holiday Cookie Cutter Set

This well-known Martha Stewart Everyday set from the early 2000s gained popularity because of its classic, simple shapes. Many collectors look for this brand due to its history of high-quality kitchen products. Sets typically include a tree, reindeer, star, mitten, and gingerbread figure. Values usually range from US $18 to US $30. Packaging that remains intact tends to raise the value.

Buyers appreciate how closely the designs match Martha Stewart’s recognizable holiday style. The brand’s association with baking traditions makes the pieces appealing to collectors. Metal cutters that remain straight and shiny attract immediate attention. Many people enjoy finding these sets unused or lightly used. Complete sets remain the most desirable.

R and M International Santa and Sleigh Cutter Set

R and M International introduced several themed cutter sets in the 1990s, including this Santa and sleigh pairing. Collectors show interest because R and M produced sturdy metal cutters with detailed outlines. This set often sells between US $12 and US $20. The recognizable shapes boost its appeal among holiday baking fans. Sets with crisp edges remain the strongest sellers.

Collectors also appreciate that R and M International designs often include charming detail work. Many sets were stored carefully, leaving them in excellent condition. People look for examples with smooth edges and no rust. The two-piece pairing creates a nice display option. Sets featuring both pieces together sell more quickly.

This article originally appeared on Avocadu.