13 Highly Valuable Vintage Toys Every Collector Dreams Of

Collectors often find great joy in uncovering rare vintage toys, with some items fetching impressive sums. The market for these toys is influenced by factors such as age, condition, and demand. For those passionate about collecting, it helps to know which toys are considered the most valuable. These items are not only significant for their nostalgic value but also for their potential investment. Learning about these treasures can take your collecting journey to the next level.

This post may contain affiliate links, which helps keep this content free. Please read our disclosure for more info.

1978 Luke Skywalker Action Figure

The 1978 Luke Skywalker action figure is a standout item for Star Wars collectors due to its status as one of the first action figures in the series. Figures in excellent condition with original packaging are highly valuable. Some figures, especially those graded in mint condition, can sell for as much as $80,000 at auction. Even ungraded figures are worth a significant amount, typically ranging from $500 to $1,850 depending on their condition.

The figure’s value can be affected by factors such as its rarity and condition. The double-telescoping lightsaber version, in particular, is one of the most coveted. Due to the early production, many figures did not survive in perfect condition. As such, finding a well-preserved 1978 Luke Skywalker figure is a rare and valuable opportunity

Peanut Royal Blue Elephant Beanie Baby

Peanut the Royal Blue Elephant Beanie Baby is one of the rarest and most valuable Beanie Babies ever made. Released by Ty in 1995, it was produced in limited quantities and has a distinct blue color that sets it apart. In excellent condition, Peanut the Elephant can be worth as much as $2,600, though its price typically ranges between $500 and $1,000. The toy’s value can vary based on tag generation, with earlier versions being more valuable.

Beanie Baby collectors are particularly interested in those that were produced in small runs or with special features. Peanut’s rarity and the nostalgia surrounding the Beanie Baby craze add to its desirability. In addition, the high demand for rare Beanie Babies keeps its market value relatively high. As time passes, the collectible value of Peanut remains strong due to its limited availability.

PEZ Dispensers

PEZ dispensers, especially vintage ones, are highly sought after by collectors. The unique characters and limited edition releases make certain dispensers incredibly valuable. A Captain Hook dispenser from the 1950s, for example, can sell for upwards of $3,000. In general, most rare PEZ dispensers are priced between $50 and $2,000, depending on the character and condition.

PEZ dispensers have become a staple collectible due to their cultural significance and nostalgic value. Early models, including character dispensers from the 1950s and 1960s, are considered the most valuable. The condition of the dispenser and the packaging can greatly influence its market price. Collectors are particularly eager to acquire complete sets and rare variants.

The Original Monopoly Game

The original version of Monopoly, patented in 1935, is a prized item among board game collectors. Early editions of the game, especially those with unique features like patent-pending boards, are highly collectible. A 1935 edition with the original patent-pending features can fetch over $700. More typical early versions of the game can range in price from $50 to $400, depending on their condition and rarity.

Monopoly’s place in American history and its association with family game nights makes it a nostalgic collectible. Versions with original boxes and pieces in good condition are particularly valuable. The game’s lasting popularity and its evolution over time keep demand high for vintage sets. Collectors are particularly drawn to versions from the first few years of production.

Game Boy

Nintendo’s Game Boy, released in 1989, revolutionized the world of portable gaming. Early models, especially those in new or mint condition with original packaging, are now valuable collectibles. Sealed units of the Game Boy have been known to sell for as much as $8,000. Typically, used Game Boys can range in price from $70 to $600 depending on condition.

The Game Boy’s historical significance in gaming makes it highly desirable to collectors. Its compact design and the iconic games it played a role in popularizing have kept it relevant among gaming enthusiasts. Finding one in perfect condition with the original box or accessories increases its value. As with many collectibles, its demand increases over time due to nostalgia and rarity.

Mario Kart Toys

Mario Kart toys, based on the iconic Nintendo video game series, have become collectible items over the years. Early figures and cars, particularly from limited edition releases, are in high demand. A sealed Mario Kart 64 figure has sold for more than $300 in the past. Prices for these toys generally range from $10 to $300, depending on rarity, condition, and packaging.

The appeal of Mario Kart toys lies in the game’s long-standing popularity and the nostalgic value associated with it. Figures and cars from the 1990s and early 2000s are among the most valuable. Collectors often seek out limited edition items that were produced in smaller quantities. The enduring legacy of the Mario Kart franchise ensures these toys remain desirable to both collectors and fans.

Cabbage Patch Kids Dolls

Cabbage Patch Kids dolls became a major toy phenomenon in the 1980s, and their early editions are highly collectible. Dolls with unique features or packaging are especially valuable to collectors. Some rare early dolls have been known to sell for over $50,000 at auction. Most vintage Cabbage Patch dolls typically range from $50 to $500, depending on condition and rarity.

The appeal of these dolls comes from their distinctive appearance and the emotional attachment many people have to them. As one of the most iconic toys of the 1980s, they are considered nostalgic treasures. Collectors often seek out the original versions with rare facial features, clothing, or accessories. The market for these dolls continues to thrive, making them a lasting collectible.

Teddy Ruxpin

Teddy Ruxpin, an animatronic bear introduced in the 1980s, became a beloved toy for many children. Early versions of Teddy Ruxpin in working condition with original tapes are highly sought after. A complete set can fetch as much as $1,000, with typical prices ranging from $50 to $300. The toy’s technological innovation and nostalgic value contribute to its collectible appeal.

Teddy Ruxpin’s ability to tell stories through cassette tapes set it apart from other toys of its time. It was one of the first toys to incorporate advanced animatronic features, which makes it an important piece of toy history. Collectors are particularly interested in obtaining fully functional units with original packaging. As time passes, the toy’s nostalgic value keeps demand high.

Faker Action Figure

Faker, a character from the Masters of the Universe toy series, is a rare action figure with a dedicated collector following. It was produced in limited quantities, making it particularly valuable today. A Faker figure in mint condition can sell for over $1,000, with most figures priced between $100 and $500. The figure’s value is highly dependent on its condition, packaging, and rarity.

Faker’s distinctive look as an evil version of He-Man makes him an iconic part of the Masters of the Universe line. His limited release only adds to his desirability among collectors. Many are willing to pay a premium for a well-preserved figure, especially those with the original accessories. As with many collectible action figures, its value has increased over time due to scarcity and demand.

Lite Brite

Lite Brite, the light-up art toy introduced in the 1960s, continues to be a nostalgic favorite for many collectors. The toy allowed children to create colorful designs with pegs on a light-up board, and vintage models are especially valuable. A complete set can sell for over $200, with prices typically ranging from $20 to $100 depending on condition. The toy’s simple design and enduring appeal make it a cherished collectible.

Collectors are especially drawn to Lite Brite sets with all the original components, including pegs and templates. The vintage models from the 1960s and 1970s are the most sought after. Lite Brite’s timeless design and connection to childhood creativity keep it a popular collectible. As time passes, the rarity of well-preserved sets increases their value.

American Girl Molly Doll

The American Girl Molly Doll, one of the original characters introduced in the 1980s, is highly collectible. Dolls in excellent condition with original outfits and accessories are especially valuable. A complete Molly doll set can fetch over $1,000 at auction, with prices for individual dolls typically ranging from $100 to $500. The value is influenced by the doll’s condition and the inclusion of accessories.

American Girl dolls have become synonymous with high-quality craftsmanship and cultural relevance. As a character from the World War II era, Molly has a unique place in the American Girl collection. Collectors often seek out dolls with rare or limited edition accessories. Due to her historical significance, Molly remains a prized item among American Girl collectors.

Lionel’s Pennsylvania ‘Trail Blazer’ Train Set

Lionel’s Pennsylvania ‘Trail Blazer’ train set is a classic among model train enthusiasts, particularly because of its historical significance. Early models with the original packaging and all components are highly valuable. A complete set can sell for over $2,000, with prices typically ranging from $200 to $1,500 depending on condition. The set’s popularity and rarity make it a favorite among collectors.

Lionel train sets have been a staple in American toy history for decades. The ‘Trail Blazer’ set is particularly sought after due to its place in the evolution of model trains. Collectors are particularly interested in finding the set in complete, original condition. As with most vintage Lionel sets, its value is tied to both condition and rarity.

Vintage Atari Cartridges

Vintage Atari cartridges, particularly rare titles or those in mint condition with original packaging, have become valuable collectibles. Some rare Atari games have sold for over $1,000 at auction, making them a sought-after item for gaming enthusiasts. The value of a cartridge depends largely on its rarity and condition, with some more common titles priced as low as $10. Most Atari cartridges typically range in price from $10 to $500 depending on their rarity.

Atari’s impact on the gaming industry is reflected in the demand for vintage games and hardware. Certain titles, like E.T.,  and Air Raid, are especially valuable due to their limited production and the historical significance of the games. Collectors are particularly keen on acquiring cartridges that come with original boxes and manuals. Over time, the rarity of these games only increases their value in the market.

As the demand for vintage toys continues to grow, knowing what to look for can make all the difference in your collection. Start your collection today and watch how these rare finds can appreciate in value over time.

This article originally appeared on Avocadu.