11 Classic Tree Toppers That Have Become Collectible
Classic tree toppers are more than just decorations; they carry a sense of nostalgia and holiday magic. Over the years, some of these toppers have become highly sought after by collectors, each piece telling a story of past celebrations. Whether made of glass, wood, or metal, these toppers have a timeless appeal that adds a special touch to any holiday display. Collectors are drawn to their unique craftsmanship, the way they capture the festive spirit of bygone eras.
This post may contain affiliate links, which helps keep this content free. Please read our disclosure for more info.
Mercury Glass Angel
This mercury glass angel tree topper, often characterized by its shimmering silver or frosted finish, evokes a sense of classic elegance and nostalgia. Popular during the mid‑20th century, it features a delicate, slender angel with graceful wings, capturing the essence of holiday warmth.
The craftsmanship and subtle beauty of these angels are highly valued, and they often come with original clips or wires for easy attachment to the tree. A well-preserved mercury glass angel can typically fetch around $120, with rarer pieces or those in excellent condition reaching up to $200. The angel’s vintage charm makes it a sought‑after collectible among those passionate about Christmas decorations.
Aluminum Tinsel Starburst
The aluminum tinsel starburst topper was a popular design during the 1950s and 1960s, often seen at the peak of mid‑century modern holiday décor. Featuring a burst of metallic tinsel radiating out from a central point, this topper adds a dazzling sparkle to any tree. The lightweight tinsel is arranged in a symmetrical design, creating a starburst effect that catches the light beautifully.
These toppers can be found for prices ranging from $45 to $75, though those in near‑mint condition or with original packaging may be valued higher. The metallic sheen of these toppers represents the optimism of the 1950s and continues to be a favored collectible for those who appreciate mid‑century style.
Blow Mold Lit Santa Head
This blow mold Santa Claus head tree topper, crafted from molded plastic, brings a sense of fun and whimsy to holiday décor. First popularized in the 1960s, the Santa head is designed to light up when plugged into a socket, casting a warm glow across the tree. The details on these toppers, from the rosy cheeks to the jolly expression, evoke the festive spirit of Christmas.
Depending on its condition, a blow mold Santa head can be worth between $80 and $120, with particularly rare or well-maintained versions fetching up to $150. These toppers are often a favorite for their nostalgic charm and playful design, appealing to collectors who enjoy adding a lighthearted touch to their tree.
Blown Glass Flame Finial
The blown glass flame finial tree topper, shaped like a candle flame, has been a beloved design for generations, offering a classic look that complements traditional holiday décor. Made from delicate, hand-blown glass, these toppers often feature a rich array of colors or sometimes a clear design with a gold or silver coating.
These pieces typically sell for around $60, with some especially vibrant or well-preserved examples fetching up to $90. The use of hand-blown glass speaks to an era when quality craftsmanship was at the forefront of holiday decoration. Its timeless design continues to resonate with those who enjoy vintage Christmas décor and seek a more refined topper for their tree.
Nutcracker Tree Topper
This nutcracker tree topper has become a symbol of the holiday season, known for its traditional appeal and connection to the famous “Nutcracker” ballet. Typically painted in festive red, green, and gold, these toppers feature a nutcracker figure or soldier with a regal, upright posture. These toppers were commonly handmade or created by artisans, making each piece unique with slight variations in design.
A well-preserved wooden nutcracker can usually be found for around $70, though rare or vintage versions from renowned makers may fetch up to $120. These toppers are especially popular during the holiday season for their connection to a beloved Christmas story and their nostalgic charm. Their handmade nature adds to their collectible value, making them a coveted item for those who love traditional Christmas décor.
Sterling Silver Snowflake
The sterling silver snowflake tree topper represents a luxurious and elegant way to finish off a Christmas tree. Made from fine sterling silver or sometimes silver-plated metal, this delicate topper features a snowflake design that sparkles in the holiday lights. The intricate detailing and shine of the silver provide a sophisticated contrast to the typical holiday ornaments.
A sterling silver snowflake topper can be worth anywhere between $150 and $250, depending on its design and condition. Pieces with elaborate filigree or rare maker marks can fetch even higher prices. The allure of silver and its connection to winter imagery makes this topper a favorite for those who appreciate high-end, timeless holiday decorations.
Ceramic Santa Claus Tree Topper
This piece presents a full Santa Claus bust or figure made from molded ceramic or plaster often painted by hand. These toppers were common in the 1930s through 1950s especially in homes that favored handmade looking décor.
Collectors look for intact ceramic with no chips or cracks and original paint with minimal wear. A well preserved topper often sells around $65. Pieces with strong vivid paint and original stand or attachments can fetch up to $100.
Glass Mercury Topper
This glass mercury tree topper features radiating rods made of mercury glass. A common feature in mid-century holiday décor, the glass rods are designed to reflect light in multiple directions, creating a shimmering effect that enhances the beauty of the tree. The design remains popular among collectors who appreciate its bold, striking appearance and the nostalgic feel it provides.
A well-preserved glass mercury topper can typically be found for $90, while especially reflective examples or those with original packaging can be worth up to $130. Its unique design and the shiny, reflective quality of the glass continue to make it a standout piece in vintage holiday collections. Its beauty and connection to mid-century modern design make it a favorite for collectors.
Cotton Batting Snowman Head Topper
Made from soft cotton batting, this snowman head topper is a charming, vintage holiday decoration that exudes a cozy, handmade feel. Often topped with a tiny scarf or hat, these snowman toppers were crafted by hand, making each one unique. The cotton batting gives the snowman a soft, textured appearance, contrasting with more rigid tree toppers made from glass or plastic.
A well-preserved cotton batting snowman head topper typically sells for around $30, while those with original accessories like a scarf or hat can fetch $50 or more. Pieces that have retained their original vibrancy and minimal wear tend to have higher value in the market. Its nostalgic charm and vintage appeal make it a perfect example of handmade holiday tradition.
Spun Cotton Fairy Angel Topper
This spun cotton fairy or angel tree topper is a classic representation of vintage holiday décor. Featuring soft cotton fibers spun into delicate wings and body, these toppers were often adorned with glitter and painted details on the face and clothing. Popular in the early to mid-20th century, the spun cotton fairy angel embodies a whimsical, gentle holiday spirit.
A spun cotton fairy angel topper in good condition typically sells for $60, with rarer or particularly well-preserved versions reaching up to $110. These unique toppers stand out due to their soft, textured appearance and ethereal quality. Their gentle, vintage appeal continues to make them highly collectible among those who cherish handcrafted Christmas decorations.
Styrofoam Santa Stack Topper
The early Styrofoam Santa stack topper is a quirky and playful addition to vintage holiday décor, made up of stacked Santa heads or snowman faces crafted from Styrofoam. This topper was a popular choice in the 1960s due to its lightweight nature and affordability. Each stacked Santa head is often painted in traditional reds and whites, capturing the iconic look of Santa Claus with a bit of playful whimsy.
A well-maintained Styrofoam Santa stack topper typically sells for around $40, though rare or particularly well-preserved versions can go up to $65. The fun and lighthearted design continue to make this topper a popular collectible among those who love vintage holiday items. Its nostalgic appeal makes it a standout piece for collectors looking for something a little different from more traditional tree toppers.
This article originally appeared on Avocadu.