10 Beanie Babies That Still Sell for Real Money

Since their debut in 1993, Beanie Babies have been known for their cute designs, unique tags, and the craze they sparked among collectors. Ty Inc., the company behind them, created a global obsession with these plush animals, many of which are now worth more than their original price. Even though some Beanie Babies lost their value over time, others continue to fetch high prices. If you have a few older Beanie Babies in your collection, it might be time to check if one of them could be worth a significant amount. Keep reading to see which Beanie Babies are still hot sellers today.

This post may contain affiliate links, which helps keep this content free. Please read our disclosure for more info.

Princess Diana Bear

Released in 1997 by Ty Inc., the Princess Diana Bear was created as a tribute to the late Princess of Wales. It initially sold for around $10 USD. The bear’s value lies in its emotional significance and the unique design, with its purple and white color scheme and a white rose on its chest. Due to its limited release and the special meaning behind it, certain versions now sell for around $500 to $2,000 USD depending on condition and tag details. Many buyers consider it an iconic collectible from the Beanie Babies craze.

Collectors look for the earliest versions with intact swing and tush tags. A version with tag errors or other misprints can fetch even higher prices. The sentimental value of this bear combined with its rarity in mint condition makes it highly desirable. Buyers will often compare recent sales to ensure the asking price is aligned with the current market. Having the bear in its original packaging can also help increase its appeal.

Brownie the Bear (later renamed Cubbie)

Brownie the Bear was released in 1993 and was part of Ty’s initial launch of Beanie Babies. Originally priced around $5 to $7 USD, it quickly became a favorite. The bear was later renamed Cubbie, but the original version remains more valuable due to its limited production and error tags. In recent sales, mint condition versions have gone for about $1,300 USD. This particular bear is sought after by collectors due to its historical place in Beanie Baby history.

To determine its worth, collectors should ensure the tag includes the original Brownie name. Bears with wear or incorrect tags are less valuable, so condition is key. Finding one with the original name intact adds substantial value. These variations make it a sought-after item for long-time Beanie Baby collectors. Many buyers prefer purchasing it in original, undisturbed packaging to preserve its condition.

Millennium Bear

The Millennium Bear was released in late 1999 as a special edition to mark the turn of the millennium. It was initially priced around $8 to $10 USD. The bear features a unique design, with its silver star embroidered on the chest, marking the new century. As a limited-edition release, this bear quickly became a collector’s item, and some versions now fetch $250 to $600 USD. Its historical significance, along with its limited availability, has contributed to its enduring demand.

Collectors appreciate the bear’s association with a significant historical moment. The silver star and special embroidery are key details that increase its desirability. Additionally, the bear’s full-size tags and absence of damage or fading can significantly impact its value. Finding a pristine version in its original packaging boosts the item’s appeal further. The Millennium Bear continues to hold a place as one of the more sought-after Beanie Babies in the collection.

Peace the Bear

Peace the Bear was introduced in 1996 as part of a collection focused on peace and harmony. Initially priced at $10 USD, its vibrant tie-dye colors and peace symbol on the chest caught the attention of collectors. The bear became one of the most recognized Beanie Babies, and versions with early tag errors have sold for as much as $1,000 USD. The bear’s meaningful theme, combined with its collectible rarity, keeps it in demand today.

Collectors seek out versions with the correct tags, especially those with minor tag errors that add rarity. The quality of the tie-dye pattern and the condition of the plush are key factors in pricing. As with many Beanie Babies, those with minimal wear or fading will command a higher price. Tag condition, particularly the swing tag and tush tag, plays a crucial role in determining value. This bear’s association with peace makes it an enduring symbol for collectors worldwide.

Claude the Crab

Claude the Crab was part of the 1996 series and retailed for around $7 USD when first released. Its colorful tie-dye pattern and unique shape made it a standout among the other Beanie Babies. Although not as widely recognized as other Beanie Babies, Claude remains highly collectible, especially those with specific tag errors or in pristine condition. Some of the rarer editions of this crab have been sold for $4,000 USD or more.

Collectors look for versions with the original tags and proper stitching on the claws. The rarity of the tag, combined with the vibrant color scheme, makes it highly sought after by serious collectors. Because many were used as playthings, finding one in near-mint condition can be quite valuable. The uniqueness of this Beanie Baby, especially with error tags, has led to a steady market for buyers. If you’re looking to sell one, confirming the tag generation and checking for any visible wear will help determine its value.

Peanut the Royal Blue Elephant

Peanut the Royal Blue Elephant was introduced in 1996, a limited-edition version of the standard Peanut elephant. Originally priced around $10 USD, it quickly became a rare item due to its deep royal blue color. Today, mint-condition examples of this bear often sell for $800 USD or more. Peanut’s rarity, combined with its vibrant color and the special edition production, makes it a prized collectible.

Buyers of Peanut the Royal Blue Elephant pay close attention to the tag details, as early versions with original PVC pellets are particularly valuable. The blue color is key to its desirability, and any sign of wear on the plush or fading of the color can lower its price. Tag condition also plays a large part in determining its worth, as damaged tags can negatively impact its market value. This elephant continues to be a favorite among Beanie Baby enthusiasts. If you have one in pristine condition, it’s worth checking auction prices and sold listings for similar items.

Garcia the Bear

Garcia the Bear was introduced in 1998 as a tribute to musician Jerry Garcia. It was initially priced around $9 USD, which was standard for Beanie Babies at the time. Garcia’s unique tie-dye appearance and the special edition’s limited production make it a standout collectible. Some rare versions of this bear now sell for $1,300 USD and more, especially those with specific tag variations. This limited release, tied to a cultural icon, has solidified its place in Beanie Baby history.

Tag variations and the presence of the original swing tag are crucial to determining Garcia’s value. Many buyers focus on finding versions with certain misprints or the absence of date errors, as these increase rarity. Garcia’s limited run as a tribute item boosts its desirability. Condition is particularly important with this bear, as many were handled by children. If you own one in mint condition, it’s well worth checking the tag details and comparing them to recent sales.

Valentino the Bear

Valentino the Bear was released in 1993, a year that marked the beginning of the Beanie Baby craze. Initially priced at around $5 USD, this bear quickly became a fan favorite due to its red heart-shaped tag and its association with Valentine’s Day. What sets this bear apart is the large number of misprinted tags and the special edition heart symbol, making certain versions more desirable. In today’s market, Valentino can fetch anywhere from $500 to $1,500 USD depending on the condition and the tag version.

Collectors often seek Valentino with the correct PVC tush tag and the original swing tag in pristine condition. The bear’s tag misprints-particularly those with incorrect birthdates or the absence of the PVC tag-are the most valuable. Even slight wear or fading on the heart tag can reduce its value. For those selling, finding a complete, unblemished version with both tags intact will yield the highest prices. Its romantic theme and nostalgic value keep it in high demand year after year.

Chocolate the Moose

Chocolate the Moose was released in 1996, with an initial retail price of $7 USD. This moose is one of the original Beanie Babies that gained popularity due to its unique brown and tan color scheme and its cute, floppy ears. What makes this moose particularly valuable is its limited run and the fact that many early editions have tag errors or are stuffed with PVC pellets. The current value for a mint-condition Chocolate the Moose is typically $500 to $1,000 USD, depending on the tag version and condition.

Collectors look for Chocolate the Moose with the correct tags and the original stuffing of PVC pellets. Tags should be intact and in great condition, as any creases or marks reduce its value. The bear’s rarity-coupled with its nostalgic appeal-keeps the demand strong. Those with a clean, undamaged look, including no fading in the tag details, will attract the highest offers. If you’re looking to sell, keep the original tags and packaging if available, as this will increase its worth.

Boo the Bear

Boo the Bear, introduced in 1998, is another Beanie Baby that remains highly collectible. Initially priced at around $8 USD, it was part of the original Attic Treasures collection. What sets Boo apart is its unique design and the fact that it was produced in limited quantities, making it harder to find than some other Beanie Babies. Recent market prices for Boo the Bear have ranged between $400 and $1,200 USD, with the highest values being for the version with no errors in the tags.

For collectors, finding Boo with a pristine tag and no damage to the fabric is crucial to maximizing its value. The stuffed animal’s connection to the Attic Treasures collection and its popularity among enthusiasts gives it lasting appeal. Its price point remains high, especially when the bear is in mint condition. Buyers seeking to purchase Boo the Bear should ensure the tags are still intact and free from creases. The bear’s rarity and continued popularity in auctions ensure that it remains in demand.

This article originally appeared on Avocadu.