14 Rare Fishing Reels That Anglers Collect Like Art

For many anglers, fishing reels go beyond their practical purpose and become a passion for collecting. Some reels are crafted with such detail and skill that they are considered masterpieces. Rare fishing reels are sought after not just for their functionality but for their historical significance and unique design. Whether you are a seasoned collector or just starting out, there is always something new to discover in the world of fishing reels.

This post may contain affiliate links, which helps keep this content free. Please read our disclosure for more info.

Hardy Perfect Fly Reel

This model was introduced by Hardy Bros in England in the early 1900s. It is known for its ball‑bearing system and high quality finish. On today’s market a well‑preserved version can fetch around $1,000–$3,000 USD, with rarer sizes crossing higher numbers. Because so many were used hard or restored, condition plays a major role in value. Collectors often look for original markings, minimal corrosion, and intact spools.

What adds to its appeal is its place in angling history and the fact that several variants exist in limited numbers. Many examples have been refinished or modified, reducing the value of those pieces. It is wise to check for signs of original foot stamps, correct finish, and any repairs before purchase. Some very rare wide‑spool versions from the 1920s have sold in excess of $5,000 USD in the right condition. This reel bridges function and collectible heritage in a way that standard reels do not.

Hardy Bougle Heritage Fly Reel (1939)

This reel was released in 1939 as part of Hardy’s Bougle series. It features a gun‑metal finish and was one of the last pre‑war production models. Current market estimates place mint condition examples in the region of $700–$1,500 USD depending on size and accessories. Its rarity is tied to limited production around wartime and the fact many were heavily used. Collectors pay attention to original spools, finish integrity, and whether the drag mechanism functions correctly.

In addition, this piece appeals because it marks a transition era in reel manufacturing. Finding one with original box or documentation boosts value. Some models with matching numbering or special foot stamps might go beyond the common range. For those interested in vintage fly reels the Bougle Heritage stands out as a solid collectible. It offers a balance of historical interest and attainable value.

Abu Garcia Ambassadeur C 7000 Round Reel

This particular model from Abu Garcia of Sweden emerged in the 1970s when the company was already well‑established in lots of global markets. Its standout feature is high speed gearing and alloy construction suited for serious fishing. Estimates for rare examples range from $500–$1,200 USD, though boxed mint examples may exceed that. The value increases when the reel is an early variant, has low serial number, or original accessories. Many sell for standard levels simply because so many exist, making true rarities more prized.

Collectors often focus on the earliest production runs, limited colour variants, and Made in Sweden labels. Condition matters a great deal: worn finish, missing parts or heavy use drag down value significantly. For anyone looking to add an Ambassadeur to a collection, getting one with original box or provenance is key. It stands in a class of reels that bridge fishing use and collectible status. The Ambassadeur line continues to enjoy interest from anglers and collectors alike.

Penn International VIS 2‑Speed Reel

This model by Penn was introduced in the late 1980s as a high‑end big game reel with 2‑speed gearing. Its aluminium body and rugged design made it popular for saltwater use. Market values for clean, boxed units hover around $800–$1,800 USD, with rare colour or special edition models higher. The rarity is largely driven by limited production runs and the decline of heavy use examples over time. Collectors look for serial number matching, original handle options and spool configurations.

What makes it stand out in collection circles is its performance heritage and condition relative scarcity. Many were used hard in demanding saltwater conditions and show heavy wear or corrosion today. An example with minimal wear and full accessories will command a premium. If you find one with original box and tag it is more likely to be considered collectible. The Penn International VIS has both functional history and collectible value.

Charles Alvey and Son Side‑Cast Fishing Reel

This reel from the historic maker Charles Alvey and Son of England dates to the early 1900s, featuring side‑cast design and fine engraving. Collectors estimate values between $300–$800 USD for clean pieces, depending on condition and rarity. Its scarcity arises because fewer side‑cast models were made in that era, and many have been lost or heavily worn. Original roshette plate, finishing touches and minimal pitting matter greatly. Many examples have missing parts or restored bodies which lower value.

This reel appeals for its historical craftsmanship and decorative features uncommon in modern reels. Finding one with original finishing, markings and minimal wear is challenging. Preservation often means no polishing, original foot, and original screws. For a collector it offers a link to early reel design and elegance. It may not reach the six‑figure range but holds strong value for a niche interest.

Hardy Marquis LWT Fly Fishing Reel

The Hardy Marquis LWT was introduced in the late 1960s as a lighter weight fly reel for more performance‑oriented anglers. Its aluminium alloy body and modern finish made it stand out at the time. Today clean examples change hands at approximately $400–$900 USD, with mint boxed versions higher. The reason it qualifies among collectors is its limited run, light weight build and association with a key brand. Many were used hard and so finding one with minimal wear adds value.

The Marquis appeals to those who want a vintage reel with a more modern look, bridging classic and contemporary. Look for original foot stamp, handle condition and spool finish. Any mods or aftermarket parts may reduce value. If you see one described as original factory finish, no polish it is likely to command the higher end of the range. It offers both usability and display appeal in one package.

ORIGIN II Fly Reel

The Origin II Fly Reel came into production during the early 2000s (though modern in comparison) and is often recognized for its precision machining and limited edition runs. Because it had numbered runs and special finishes it is increasingly collected. Estimated market value ranges from $300–$600 USD depending on edition and condition. Rarity is driven by specific finish variants, limited production numbers and the fact many were used for fishing rather than preserved. Collectors will check for original certificate of authenticity and limited edition numbering.

What gives it extra appeal is the combination of modern performance and collectible status. While not as old as many classic reels, the limited nature of certain editions places it ahead in collector interest. If you locate one with original box and paperwork it will hold more value. Some editions have unique engraving or colour that makes them sought after. It is a good example of a reel that invites both use and display.

Pflueger Worth Jeweled Reel (circa 1915)

This model was produced around 1915 and features decorative jeweled bearings and a leather case. Market listings show values of approximately $250–$600 USD for good condition models. The collectible value comes from its age, ornate finishing and the scarcity of such decorative reels from that era. Condition of the jeweled parts, presence of original leather case and minimal rust matter significantly. Many examples show heavy wear or missing jewels, which reduces value.

Collectors value this piece for its combination of function and decoration from a bygone era. It offers a slice of early reel design where beauty mattered as much as performance. If you find one with full original jewels and matching case it will command a premium. For display purposes it holds strong appeal. It reminds us of a time when fishing gear was made with both form and function in mind.

Mitchell Garcia 300 Spinning Reel (Vintage 1960s)

Introduced during the 1960s by Garcia (later Mitchell) this spinning reel was considered advanced for its time. Market values for rare boxed units hover around $150–$400 USD, though unboxed or heavily used versions go for much less. The rarity stems from limited availability of early production models in good condition with paperwork. Collectors will check for original box, handle type, spool finish and serial numbers. Many were used hard and repainted, which lowers value.

This reel is meaningful because it represents a popular brand at a transitional time in spinning reel technology. For collectors of spinning reels, rather than fly or baitcasting it offers a chance at a historic piece. If you find one described as original finish, no repaint you will be in good territory. It bridges everyday angling gear and collectible items. While not ultra high value compared to some rare fly reels it offers nice collectible potential.

Abbey and Imbrie Gold Rod and Reel Set (1876)

Released in 1876 for the Centennial Exposition and made in extremely limited numbers, this set includes solid gold mountings and intricate decoration. Market reports have placed values at $50,000–$100,000 USD or more when provenance is verified. Rarity is extremely high: only a few sets are known to survive. Condition, originality, mounting type and documentation all move the value dramatically. Many potential buyers will demand meticulous verification before purchase.

This set is regarded as near the top in fishing tackle collecting; it is as much art decorative piece as fishing gear. For most collectors it is a dream item rather than attainable purchase. If you ever see one listed you are looking at a premium market. It stands at the confluence of angling history, high craftsmanship and decorative luxury. It demonstrates how fishing reels and gear can reach the level of fine collectibles.

 

Abel SDF Solid Fly Reel (4-5 wt)

Released in the 2000s, this reel from Abel is known for its solid machin­ed body and limited finish runs. Collectors estimate value at around $500–$1,000 USD, especially for special finish models. Its rarity comes from both low production numbers and the fact many were custom ordered, making those with documented provenance more desirable. Condition matters: unused or lightly fished examples with original box or tools will command more. Many users fished them hard, reducing available mint examples.

This reel appeals because it blends modern manufacturing with collectible appeal. The fact that it is still usable makes it attractive for those who both collect and fish. Special finishes such as Brook Trout or other themed designs elevate value further. It is a model that represents more recent vintage yet obtains collector attention. If you see one with original paperwork and unique serial number it will likely sit at the top end of the range.

Edward vom Hofe Big Game Reel (No. 722 12-0, circa early 1900s)

This model by Edward vom Hofe around the early 1900s (size 722, 12-0) was made for serious salt‑water fishing and has become sought after by collectors. Recent auction listings show values around $4,000–$6,000 USD for clean, boxed examples. Rarity comes from its age, craftsmanship, and large size for big‑game use. Collectors check for original handle, patent plate, and absence of significant restoration. Many of these reels were heavy used, reducing numbers in good condition.

What makes it special is the combination of engineering, size and heritage. It is part of angling lore when big game fishing grew in the early 20th century. If you find one with original leather case and documented history it may command higher value. It is a trophy piece for someone serious about fishing gear collecting. The fact that it is still functionally capable adds to its story.

South Bend St. Joe Wide Body Reel (1935)

Produced around 1935, this wide body model has heavy duty construction and is sought after by collectors of American vintage reels. Values for clean examples are typically in the range of $200–$500 USD, and higher if boxed or in mint condition. Its rarity is due to limited production of that variant and moderate survival over the decades. Collectors look for wide body spool, original foot stamp, and minimal corrosion. Many survive in poor condition so good ones stand out.

What makes it interesting is the American origin and the era it comes from. A wide-body reel from the ’30s with original finish offers both historical and aesthetic appeal. When paired with original box or pamphlet, it will rise in value. For someone entering reel collecting it presents a reasonable entry point. It reminds us of the transition period between earlier fishing tackle design and later mass‑production.

Shakespeare Wonder‑Cast 1788 Reel (Vintage 1940s)

This spinning/traditional model made in the 1940s by Shakespeare with model number 1788 is known for its distinctive finish and style. Typical market values for a clean example range from $100–$300 USD depending on condition and accessories. Its collectibility comes from age, unusual design and moderate scarcity in good condition. Many units have been modified or repainted which reduces collectible value. Collectors look for original finish, original handle, and intact spool.

While the value is modest compared to ultra‑rare models it offers an accessible entry into reel collecting. It gives display appeal and a decent connection to mid‑20th‑century fishing gear. If you find one with original box or documentation it will move up in value. For someone looking to enjoy both fishing gear and collectible history it provides good value. It underscores how even lesser‑known models have appeal in the collector world.

This article originally appeared on Avocadu.