14 Underrated Fall Movies Everyone Should See Once
There is something about fall that makes us crave a good movie, especially the ones that fly under the radar. While the obvious picks get plenty of attention, some truly remarkable films have gone unnoticed. These underrated movies have that special something that makes them stand out. With the cozy season in full swing, it is the perfect time to explore films you may have missed.
This post may contain affiliate links, which helps keep this content free. Please read our disclosure for more info.
Hocus Pocus (1993)
“Hocus Pocus” brings together quirky witches, a magical town, and a haunting yet humorous atmosphere. Set during Halloween, this film has become a seasonal favorite for its lighthearted charm. The dynamic between the mischievous Sanderson sisters and the kids who try to stop them keeps the audience engaged throughout. It perfectly captures the essence of fall with its magical, spooky vibe and cozy setting.
While it may have flown under the radar when first released, “Hocus Pocus” has grown into a beloved classic. The film’s playful antics and whimsical elements make it ideal for fall nights. Its colorful visuals and memorable performances from Bette Midler, Sarah Jessica Parker, and Kathy Najimy give it a timeless appeal. This one will always make you look forward to the season of pumpkins and ghosts.
The Secret Garden (1993)
Based on the beloved novel, “The Secret Garden” brings the warmth of nature into an isolated, chilly world. The story of an orphaned girl discovering the magical power of a hidden garden fits perfectly with the themes of renewal and fall change. The film’s slow pacing and beautiful scenery create a peaceful atmosphere, perfect for a quiet autumn evening. As Mary Lennox breathes life into the garden, the audience too feels rejuvenated by its charm.
This version of “The Secret Garden” captures the magic of childhood wonder and the serenity of nature in a way that feels timeless. The misty moors, the old manor house, and the hidden corners of the garden all make it feel like you’re stepping into a fall fairy tale. The film speaks to the power of growth, making it an ideal watch as the seasons change. Its soothing narrative and lush visuals will leave you feeling warm and reflective.
Dead Poets Society (1989)
“Dead Poets Society” speaks to the heart of autumn with its story of young minds discovering freedom and self-expression. Set in a prep school, the film is an exploration of the power of literature and individual thought, all framed by the changing seasons. Robin Williams gives a performance that lingers long after the credits roll, inspiring audiences to seek out the beauty in their own lives. His character, John Keating, encourages his students to seize the day, making it a perfect fall watch as the year winds down.
While the film may focus on deep themes of loss and growth, its message of finding one’s voice resonates with the spirit of autumn. The picturesque fall setting, combined with the warmth of a teacher who sees potential in every student, creates a comforting yet thought-provoking atmosphere. “Dead Poets Society” is a reminder of the value of finding your own path, making it a timeless choice for reflection.
The Others (2001)
If you’re in the mood for something atmospheric yet mysterious, “The Others” offers a chilling tale set in a secluded mansion. The film’s eerie, foggy backdrop makes it an excellent choice for a fall evening, where you can sink into its haunting atmosphere. Nicole Kidman’s portrayal of a mother protecting her children from a supernatural force is compelling, and the slow-burning suspense keeps you engaged. The film is masterful in its use of light and shadows, enhancing the spooky, unsettling mood.
Though it may not be as widely recognized, “The Others” stands out as a subtle and sophisticated horror film. It focuses more on tension and atmosphere than cheap scares, which makes it feel fresh and timeless. The autumn season, with its long, chilly nights and muted sunlight, complements the film’s tone perfectly. Its gripping narrative will leave you thinking long after the movie ends.
October Sky (1999)
“October Sky” is the heartwarming story of a young boy in a coal mining town who dreams of becoming a rocket scientist. The film’s focus on family, ambition, and perseverance makes it a perfect watch as the fall season ushers in a time of reflection. Jake Gyllenhaal delivers a heartfelt performance as Homer Hickam, who refuses to be limited by his circumstances. The backdrop of small-town life and the changing leaves adds to the film’s nostalgic, hopeful feel.
The movie is deeply comforting in its portrayal of a community coming together to support a young dreamer. With its autumn setting and themes of determination, “October Sky” is a reminder that it’s never too late to reach for the stars. The family dynamics are relatable, and the movie’s message of following your passion resonates strongly in the fall, a season often associated with new beginnings and change.
The Village (2004)
“The Village” combines mystery, suspense, and a haunting atmosphere that pairs perfectly with the fall season. The film is set in a secluded village surrounded by dark woods, creating an unsettling yet captivating backdrop. M. Night Shyamalan’s tale of fear and secrecy draws you in with its eerie visuals and slowly unfolding narrative. The story’s sense of isolation and mystery is amplified by the seasonal imagery of trees losing their leaves and fog filling the air.
While it may not be for everyone, “The Village” is a brilliant film that invites you to ponder deeper questions about fear and the unknown. Its muted color palette and slow-burning tension make it an ideal fall film. The unsettling atmosphere and the village’s secrets are revealed in a way that keeps you guessing. “The Village” is perfect for those who enjoy a story that challenges the mind while stirring up emotions.
Practical Magic (1998)
“Practical Magic” is a cozy, witchy classic that effortlessly blends charm and enchantment. The story centers on two sisters, played by Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman, who must deal with family curses while navigating their magical powers. Set against the backdrop of a small, picturesque New England town, this film brings a comforting, autumnal feel with its rich colors and mysterious vibe. The magical realism mixed with the deep emotional bond between the sisters makes it an ideal movie for fall.
The film balances lighthearted moments with more serious themes of love and loss, making it both fun and poignant. The iconic witchcraft themes, coupled with a Halloween vibe, make it a must-watch during the fall. Its heartwarming storyline and magical elements offer the perfect escape into a world of wonder. Whether you’re watching it for the first time or revisiting it, “Practical Magic” will fill your home with autumnal warmth.
The Cider House Rules (1999)
Set in a rural Maine orphanage, “The Cider House Rules” explores themes of choice, morality, and love against the backdrop of a changing fall landscape. The film follows Homer Wells, a young man who comes of age while struggling with his identity and purpose. The strong performances by Tobey Maguire and Michael Caine anchor this poignant drama, which resonates with the season’s focus on change and growth. The crisp fall air and rustic setting create a comforting backdrop for this heartfelt story.
The film’s exploration of personal responsibility and moral dilemmas makes it perfect for fall, a time of reflection and inward growth. With its autumnal setting and thought-provoking themes, “The Cider House Rules” offers both beauty and depth. The movie’s mix of warmth and introspection fits well with the season’s mood, making it an ideal pick for a cozy fall evening. It’s a film that stays with you long after the credits roll.
Planes, Trains, and Automobiles (1987)
“Planes, Trains, and Automobiles” is a classic comedy that combines humor with the spirit of the season. John Candy and Steve Martin deliver memorable performances as two mismatched travelers trying to make it home for Thanksgiving. Set against the backdrop of bustling airports, snowy roads, and autumn landscapes, the film captures the essence of travel during the holidays. The blend of slapstick humor and heartwarming moments makes this a perfect fall film.
This movie is comforting in its portrayal of unlikely friendships and the holiday spirit. As the characters face travel disasters, they learn about the kindness of strangers and the importance of human connection. The autumn and winter setting provides a cozy backdrop, enhancing the film’s emotional depth. “Planes, Trains, and Automobiles” remains a must-watch for its warmth and laughs.
Fantastic Mr. Fox (2009)
“Fantastic Mr. Fox” brings the whimsical world of Roald Dahl’s novel to life with its unique stop-motion animation. The film, set in a forest full of clever animals, combines wit and charm in a way that feels perfect for the fall season. The colorful autumn leaves and vibrant landscapes give the film a cozy, nostalgic feel. Wes Anderson’s direction ensures that the story, though aimed at children, appeals to audiences of all ages.
The film’s themes of family, adventure, and individuality resonate deeply in the fall, a season of change and growth. Its distinct animation style and quirky humor make it stand out as a visual treat. The interactions between the characters, particularly Mr. Fox’s attempts to outsmart the farmers, provide both humor and heart. “Fantastic Mr. Fox” is a comforting watch that offers something for everyone.
Sleepy Hollow (1999)
Tim Burton’s “Sleepy Hollow” blends spooky, gothic horror with the crisp atmosphere of fall. Set in a small village during the 18th century, the film follows Ichabod Crane as he investigates mysterious deaths attributed to the legendary Headless Horseman. The eerie fog, the dark woods, and the haunting visuals make this film a perfect fit for the season of ghosts and ghouls. Burton’s signature style creates a visually striking experience that is both chilling and beautiful.
“Sleepy Hollow” captures the essence of fall through its use of atmospheric scenery and classic horror elements. The film’s lush, detailed world immerses you in a macabre version of autumn. Johnny Depp’s portrayal of the skeptical Ichabod Crane adds a layer of humor and depth to the story. If you’re looking for a spooky, yet visually stunning movie to match the fall season, this one is a must-see.
The Nightmare Before Christmas (1993)
Another Tim Burton film that beautifully captures the spirit of both Halloween and Christmas is “The Nightmare Before Christmas.” Set in the whimsical world of Halloween Town, the film tells the story of Jack Skellington’s desire to bring new meaning to the holiday season. The film’s dark yet charming visuals, paired with its hauntingly beautiful soundtrack, make it a perfect choice for fall viewing. Its blend of fantasy, music, and seasonal themes creates a unique movie experience.
The film’s lasting appeal comes from its mix of eerie visuals and heartfelt themes. It is a perfect pick for those who love both Halloween and Christmas, as it effortlessly bridges the two. The memorable characters, catchy songs, and stop-motion animation give it an unforgettable charm. Whether you’re watching it for the first time or the hundredth, “The Nightmare Before Christmas” never fails to enchant.
The Lake House (2006)
“The Lake House” is a romantic drama set against the backdrop of a serene lakeside house, where a doctor and an architect exchange letters across time. The autumn setting, with its changing colors and cool atmosphere, provides the perfect backdrop for this emotional and poignant story. Sandra Bullock and Keanu Reeves deliver heartfelt performances, making the movie both captivating and comforting. The gentle pace of the film, combined with the mystery surrounding the time-traveling mailbox, creates a dreamy, reflective atmosphere.
The film’s timeless themes of love, loss, and destiny resonate deeply, making it a great movie for the fall season. The picturesque lake, the crisp air, and the autumn leaves all add to the story’s sense of longing and connection. “The Lake House” offers a warm and wistful escape, making it a perfect pick for those looking for a romantic, slow-burn drama. This film is ideal for cozying up during those cooler fall nights.
Little Women (2019)
Greta Gerwig’s adaptation of “Little Women” breathes new life into the classic story of the March sisters, set during the late 1800s. With its rich autumnal scenes, the film captures the essence of fall through its sweeping landscapes and intimate family moments. Saoirse Ronan, Emma Watson, Florence Pugh, and Timothée Chalamet bring the beloved characters to life, making this version both fresh and nostalgic. The movie is a celebration of sisterhood, dreams, and personal growth, with the changing seasons reflecting the changes in the characters’ lives.
The film’s warmth and heartfelt moments make it a comforting choice for fall, a season associated with both change and tradition. Its beautiful cinematography, combined with strong performances, brings the classic novel to life in a way that feels both timeless and modern. “Little Women” is perfect for those who love stories that focus on family, ambition, and the bonds that shape us. The film’s emotional depth and visual beauty make it a must-watch during the autumn months.
This article originally appeared on Avocadu.