13 Rare Halloween Cookie Jars That Collectors Can’t Resist

This post may contain affiliate links, which helps keep this content free. Please read our disclosure for more info.

McCoy Pumpkin Cookie Jar

The McCoy Pumpkin Cookie Jar is one of the most recognizable Halloween-themed collectibles from the mid-20th century. Shaped like a smiling jack-o’-lantern with a warm orange glaze, it captures the friendly side of Halloween decor. Collectors value its charm, durability, and nostalgic tie to American pottery history. Authentic pieces with intact paint and original lids can reach an estimated value of $250 depending on condition and rarity.

Those seeking this collectible often search antique markets or specialized online auctions. When verifying authenticity, the McCoy hallmark at the base should be present and clear. Chips or fading can reduce its value, but even well-loved versions are prized by collectors who appreciate vintage craftsmanship. Its cheerful pumpkin face remains a favorite centerpiece for seasonal kitchen displays.

Disney Mickey Mouse Halloween Cookie Jar

The Disney Mickey Mouse Halloween Cookie Jar delights both Disney fans and collectors of seasonal ceramics. Featuring Mickey in a pumpkin costume holding a trick-or-treat bag, this jar combines nostalgia with cheerful design. Released in limited numbers through Disney Stores, it gained collectible status soon after discontinuation. The market value ranges from $120 to $160 depending on its packaging and preservation.

Collectors love that this jar represents Disney’s approach to seasonal merchandise during the late 1990s and early 2000s. Its bright colors and glossy finish make it a standout display piece for Halloween. Keeping the original box can significantly increase its value among Disney memorabilia enthusiasts. Over time, it has become a treasured crossover collectible for fans of animation and holiday decor.

Pillsbury Doughboy Halloween Cookie Jar

The Pillsbury Doughboy Halloween Cookie Jar combines nostalgia for the brand’s mascot with the charm of Halloween decor. This design features the smiling Doughboy wearing a pumpkin-shaped outfit and holding a candy pail. Released as a promotional collectible, it became highly sought after in later years. The typical resale value ranges from $70 to $130 depending on rarity and box condition.

Collectors often associate this jar with the cheerful advertising era of the early 2000s. It captures both brand nostalgia and seasonal fun, making it popular among advertising memorabilia enthusiasts. The lightweight ceramic build makes it practical for display without risk of damage. Its friendly theme ensures that it fits easily with both kitchen decor and Halloween party setups.

Universal Monsters Cookie Jar Set

The Universal Monsters Cookie Jar Set honors classic horror icons like Dracula, Frankenstein’s Monster, and the Mummy. Released in the early 1990s, the set appealed to both movie fans and collectors of spooky memorabilia. Each jar was individually sculpted and hand-painted with fine detail. Depending on condition and completeness of the set, values range between $250 and $400.

Collectors often seek full sets rather than single pieces to preserve display consistency. Each monster’s design reflects the original film aesthetic, giving the collection strong nostalgia appeal. The limited production makes complete sets increasingly rare. Owners often showcase them during the Halloween season as a centerpiece for themed gatherings.

Peanuts Great Pumpkin Cookie Jar

The Peanuts Great Pumpkin Cookie Jar remains one of the most beloved Halloween-themed collectibles inspired by Charles Schulz’s comic strip. Featuring Linus and Snoopy waiting in a pumpkin patch, it captures the spirit of the classic television special. Released by Westland Giftware, it quickly became a collector’s item among Peanuts fans. Current market prices usually fall between $150 and $220.

Collectors appreciate its nostalgic tie to the 1966 holiday special and its bright, cartoonish style. The glossy finish enhances its display appeal, and many pieces remain in circulation in excellent shape. Keeping the original box or certificate can increase its value. For fans of vintage animation and seasonal decor, this cookie jar offers both charm and cultural significance.

The Nightmare Before Christmas Jack Skellington Cookie Jar remains one of the most iconic Halloween collectibles ever produced. Inspired by Tim Burton’s 1993 film, it showcases Jack’s skeletal grin and monochrome design that blends spooky and whimsical charm. Released by Disney and later reissued in limited editions, this jar appeals to both film lovers and collectors. Depending on the version and condition, it typically sells between $180 and $300.

Collectors appreciate its fine detailing and connection to a cult-favorite movie that bridges Halloween and Christmas themes. The lid fits snugly, and the glaze gives it a polished, high-quality appearance. Some limited-edition variants feature glow-in-the-dark paint or sculpted Zero, Jack’s ghostly dog. The continued popularity of the film keeps this cookie jar in high demand throughout the year.

Ghostbusters Stay Puft Cookie Jar

The Ghostbusters Stay Puft Cookie Jar captures the humor and nostalgia of the 1984 movie classic. Designed as the smiling marshmallow mascot, it perfectly represents a playful balance between horror and comedy. Produced by NECA and later by other licensed manufacturers, it has remained a popular collector item for decades. Its current market value typically ranges between $130 and $180.

Collectors admire its solid ceramic build and the glossy white glaze that gives the Stay Puft character a lively presence. The lid lifts off neatly from the top of his hat, revealing ample cookie storage space. Displaying it beside other pop culture memorabilia creates a nostalgic Halloween touch. Fans of retro films often consider this piece an essential addition to their themed decor.

Yankee Candle Pumpkinhead Cookie Jar

The Yankee Candle Pumpkinhead Cookie Jar originated from the company’s seasonal promotions and quickly became a collector’s item. Its grinning pumpkin face and witch’s hat design align perfectly with the company’s popular autumn fragrance of the same name. The jar’s deep orange glaze and high-gloss finish make it an attractive decorative piece. It usually sells for around $100 to $140 on resale markets.

Collectors are drawn to its recognizable branding and charming craftsmanship. The combination of collectible pottery and home fragrance marketing adds to its nostalgic appeal. Many owners keep it as part of a display with the matching Pumpkinhead candle. It remains one of the more accessible Halloween collectibles for both new and seasoned enthusiasts.

Cracker Barrel Scarecrow Cookie Jar

The Cracker Barrel Scarecrow Cookie Jar combines rustic charm with Halloween appeal. It features a friendly scarecrow with a straw hat, plaid shirt, and stitched grin. Originally sold in the restaurant’s seasonal section, it quickly became a collectible for its country-style charm. Current resale value averages between $75 and $110.

Collectors appreciate the warmth it brings to farmhouse and fall-themed interiors. The jar’s color palette of orange, brown, and yellow matches the cozy tones of autumn. Many owners pair it with matching plates or mugs from the same collection. It continues to be a popular pick for those who enjoy casual, friendly seasonal decor.

Fitz And Floyd Witch Screech Owl Cookie Jar

The Fitz and Floyd Witch Screech Owl Cookie Jar combines spooky charm with the company’s signature artistry. The jar features a witch’s owl with glowing eyes perched on a broomstick, with a highly detailed broom and hat design. It blends Halloween motifs with Fitz and Floyd’s high-quality ceramic work. This collectible is typically valued between $180 and $240 depending on condition.

The vibrant glazes, carefully painted details, and whimsical design make this jar a standout piece in any collection. Fans of the brand appreciate the precision in every brushstroke and the clear finish that enhances the jar’s appearance. It fits perfectly in both Halloween-themed displays and year-round collections of fine ceramics. Despite being somewhat niche, this jar’s rarity and craftsmanship have ensured that it holds steady demand in the collector market.

Ghost Cookie Jar

The Ghost Cookie Jar is a simple yet effective Halloween collectible that has captured the hearts of many over the years. With its friendly, smiling ghost design, it brings a lighthearted atmosphere to any kitchen during the fall season. Made from ceramic with a glossy white finish, it is an iconic piece for collectors of Halloween-themed kitchenware. Its market value is generally around $50 to $90, depending on its condition.

Collectors appreciate the jar’s cheerful aesthetic, which stands in contrast to many more sinister Halloween designs. The ghost’s large eyes and exaggerated grin make it a fun, welcoming addition to any home. Although it may not hold the highest market value, its charm and accessibility have made it a beloved seasonal piece. It is an easy way to introduce Halloween spirit without overloading on spooky imagery.

Department 56 Halloween Witch Pumpkin Cats Cookie Jar

The Department 56 Halloween Witch Pumpkin Cats Cookie Jar is a whimsical, charming piece that captures the festive side of Halloween. Featuring a friendly witch surrounded by pumpkins and playful black cats, this jar is a perfect blend of spooky and sweet. Released by Department 56, the collectible was designed with intricate details and vibrant colors that reflect the brand’s holiday spirit. Its value ranges between $200 and $250 depending on condition and completeness.

Collectors appreciate the vibrant colors and lively design that adds character to their seasonal collections. The jar is large enough to be both functional and decorative, with a lid that keeps treats fresh. Many collectors take pride in keeping the jar in pristine condition, making it a sought-after item in the Department 56 Halloween collection. Its limited availability ensures it remains a treasured collectible.

Threshold Gray Cat Stoneware Cookie Jar

The Threshold Gray Cat Stoneware Cookie Jar adds a touch of elegance to Halloween-themed collectibles. Designed in a soft gray stoneware, it features a simple, stylized cat with a friendly expression and subtle details. Released as part of Target’s seasonal collection, this jar gained popularity for its minimalist design and durability. It typically sells for around $40 to $60, making it an affordable yet collectible item.

Collectors appreciate its modern take on classic Halloween imagery. The understated design makes it suitable for year-round use, blending into a wide range of home decor styles. Despite being more contemporary, its consistent demand during Halloween seasons keeps it a popular choice for decorators. Its durability ensures that it remains a reliable and long-lasting addition to any kitchen.

This article originally appeared on Avocadu.