12 Vintage Costumes and Masks That Became Collector Pieces

Vintage Halloween costumes and masks carry a special kind of charm. They remind people of childhood nights spent trick or treating and reflect the pop culture of their time. From monster masks to superhero outfits, many have become collector favorites because of their rarity and design. These pieces show how Halloween traditions have changed while keeping their playful spirit alive.

This post may contain affiliate links, which helps keep this content free. Please read our disclosure for more info.

Ben Cooper Universal Monsters Costumes

Ben Cooper’s Universal Monsters line remains one of the most recognizable collections of Halloween costumes from the 60s and 70s. Dracula, Frankenstein’s Monster, and The Wolf Man appeared in brightly colored vinyl smocks paired with simple but striking masks. The packaging itself often featured vivid artwork, which makes boxed sets especially desirable to collectors today. These costumes were inexpensive at the time but now stand as pop culture treasures.

Collectors value the playful yet slightly eerie look of the masks, which leaned more cartoonish than frightening. Condition plays a huge role in value, with intact masks and boxes selling for far more. They also carry nostalgia for those who remember picking one out from a drugstore shelf before Halloween. As a result, they have become a staple in vintage costume collections.

Collegeville Superhero Costumes

Collegeville was another big name in Halloween wear, creating superhero outfits that rivaled Ben Cooper’s designs. Their Batman, Spider-Man, and Wonder Woman costumes were hugely popular during the 70s. The designs were colorful and eye catching, often using simple vinyl with bold logos and lightweight masks. Today, they are prized pieces for both superhero and Halloween collectors.

Finding complete sets with the box, cape, and accessories still intact is rare. Fans of comic history enjoy seeing how these costumes reflected the early popularity of heroes long before blockbuster films. They are especially appealing because they capture the simpler, hand-drawn style of comic book art from that era. Their mix of nostalgia and rarity makes them stand out in collections.

Don Post Latex Masks

Don Post Studios set new standards for realism in mask making beginning in the 1940s. By the 1970s, the company was producing latex masks of Dracula, the Mummy, and other monsters that looked much more detailed than dime store rubber. Many were even used in television and promotional events because of their lifelike features. Today, early Don Post masks are displayed more like art pieces than party wear.

Collectors treasure the durability and sculpted detail of these masks, although latex often deteriorates over time. Preserved examples are difficult to find, which increases their appeal. Some limited releases and artist-signed versions now fetch high prices at auction. For many, owning a Don Post mask is like holding a piece of horror movie history.

1960s Planet of the Apes Masks

When Planet of the Apes was released in 1968, mask makers quickly responded to the craze. Don Post in particular created latex masks resembling Cornelius, Dr. Zaius, and other ape characters. Fans were impressed with the attention to detail, which echoed the film’s groundbreaking makeup effects. These masks became essential for collectors of sci-fi memorabilia.

The masks today often show signs of age, as latex naturally cracks and fades. Even so, collectors pay top prices for well-preserved examples. Their rarity and direct tie to one of the most influential sci-fi films of the era drive demand. Owning one feels like owning a piece of cinematic history.

Topstone Ghoul Masks

Topstone masks from the 1950s through the 70s were affordable yet creative. They were made of cheap rubber and often featured wild designs like bulging eyes, fanged ghouls, or grinning skeletons. Kids bought them through comic book ads or at five-and-dime stores. Despite their low cost, they left a lasting mark on Halloween nostalgia.

Collectors love the quirky, exaggerated style of these masks. Some have even become iconic after appearing in album art and low-budget horror films. Their affordability at the time means few were saved in good condition, making surviving examples special today. They serve as reminders of how inventive Halloween products once were.

1980s Freddy Krueger Masks

The release of A Nightmare on Elm Street in 1984 made Freddy Krueger an instant horror icon. Licensed masks quickly hit shelves, allowing kids and adults to dress as the clawed villain. These latex masks featured burn-scar details, sometimes paired with the striped sweater for a full look. They remain a favorite among horror collectors.

Latex versions from the mid-80s are often fragile, so intact masks are hard to find. Collectors prize those with original packaging or retail tags still attached. Because Freddy became such a pop culture figure, these masks hold both nostalgic and display value. They mark a shift in Halloween products toward slasher movie themes.

1970s KISS Costumes

KISS’s merchandising boom in the 1970s extended into Halloween costumes. Ben Cooper produced vinyl smocks and plastic masks of Gene Simmons, Paul Stanley, Ace Frehley, and Peter Criss. Kids could dress up as their favorite rock stars, complete with the band’s trademark makeup. Full boxed sets are highly collectible today.

The rarity of complete band collections makes them especially prized. Many kids wore the costumes until they fell apart, so preserved examples are limited. They appeal to both music and Halloween collectors, creating crossover interest. These costumes reflect just how far the KISS brand extended into pop culture.

1970s Star Wars Costumes

When Star Wars debuted in 1977, merchandise exploded, including Halloween costumes. Ben Cooper released versions of Darth Vader, Luke Skywalker, Princess Leia, and Chewbacca. The costumes featured vinyl smocks printed with character names and bright plastic masks. These early products became part of the franchise’s first wave of collectibles.

Collectors search for boxed examples, as packaging often adds significant value. The masks themselves carry charm, with their colorful interpretations of the characters. They represent how quickly Star Wars seeped into every aspect of children’s lives. For fans of the saga, they are a fun and nostalgic prize.

1960s Casper the Friendly Ghost Costumes

Casper costumes by Ben Cooper reflected the lighthearted tone of the animated character. The vinyl smock often displayed Casper’s cheerful image, while the mask featured his signature wide-eyed smile. These were popular with younger children who wanted something less frightening. Today, they are collectible for both Halloween and animation fans.

The charm of these costumes lies in their simplicity. Many collectors remember wearing one themselves or seeing them in stores during October. Complete boxed sets are rare, as most were heavily used by kids. They serve as sweet reminders of mid-century Halloween traditions.

1980s Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Costumes

With the explosion of TMNT in the late 1980s, Halloween costumes soon followed. Companies like Ben Cooper released versions of Leonardo, Michelangelo, Donatello, and Raphael. These included vinyl smocks with turtle shell designs and green face masks. They quickly became a staple among children during the cartoon’s peak.

Collectors today look for boxed examples or sets that include all four turtles. They tap into strong nostalgia for the 80s cartoon era. Because many were worn and discarded, finding a full set is a challenge. They remain popular among both toy and costume collectors.

1970s Evel Knievel Costumes

During the 1970s, Evel Knievel became a household name through his daring stunts. Licensed costumes let kids wear his white jumpsuit decorated with stars and stripes. These included a mask with his likeness, creating a full representation of the stunt performer. They became popular among children fascinated by his motorcycle jumps.

Collectors today value these costumes for their unique tie to real-life pop culture rather than fiction. Sets with the mask and jumpsuit intact are hard to come by. Their patriotic designs make them visually striking for display. They stand as reminders of how Evel Knievel captured the imagination of a generation.

1960s–70s Clown Masks

Clown masks were a common sight in dime stores during the mid-20th century. They came in bright colors, with exaggerated features and wide grins. Children wore them for Halloween, but many now carry a spooky feel when viewed through a modern lens. They are a popular niche among vintage mask collectors.

Collectors look for masks in good condition, as many were cheaply made and quickly damaged. Some are remembered fondly, while others have gained cult status for their eerie look. Their range from cheerful to creepy gives them a wide appeal. They are perfect examples of how Halloween products reflected the styles of their era.