10 Old Cast Iron Pans Collectors Identify by Markings

Cast iron pans are highly prized for their durability and ability to provide even heat distribution. Collectors know that the markings on these pans can reveal a lot about their origin and history. Understanding these markings can help enthusiasts identify rare and valuable pieces. If you’re curious about the marks that make certain cast iron pans stand out, read on to discover more.

This post may contain affiliate links, which helps keep this content free. Please read our disclosure for more info.

Vintage Griswold Erie No.8 Skillet

This Griswold Erie No.8 skillet was first released around the 1900s and is highly regarded for its smooth cooking surface and long-lasting durability. Collectors often identify it by the cross and name cast in raised letters on the base. The price for well-preserved examples can range from $150 to $300, depending on the condition. The presence of a fine seasoning and sharp, clear markings can significantly increase its value.

The skillet’s handle is traditional, long, and sturdy, making it easy to handle while cooking. Vintage Griswold skillets are prized for their even heat distribution, which makes them ideal for frying, baking, or searing. Many collectors appreciate the smoothness of the interior, as it makes for an enjoyable cooking experience. This piece’s historical charm and functionality make it a sought-after item in any collection.

Antique Wagner Ware Sidney O Cast Iron Skillet

Produced in the 1920s by the Wagner foundry in Sidney, Ohio, this skillet is famous for its elegant, script-style logo. The raised oval logo on the base makes it easy to identify and adds to the appeal of this historic piece. Depending on the condition, this skillet can fetch anywhere between $80 and $220. Its rarity and collector demand can also drive the price higher for pieces in excellent condition.

This skillet is beloved for its smooth cooking surface and solid construction, which ensures even heat distribution. Many buyers appreciate the ergonomic handle, designed for comfort and control while cooking. The well-seasoned interior gives it a naturally non-stick surface, making it perfect for everyday use. Collectors often seek it out not just for cooking but as a prized piece of American cookware history.

Antique Favorite Cast Iron No.7 Skillet

The Favorite Cast Iron No.7 Skillet, dating back to the 1890s, is a classic piece of American craftsmanship. Its simple block-letter logo makes it a highly identifiable pan for collectors. A well-maintained skillet from this line typically sells for $70 to $150, though pristine examples can exceed that price. The smooth cooking surface and well-preserved markings are key factors that impact its market value.

This skillet is small enough for single-use cooking but offers excellent heat retention and distribution. The handle is thin, making it easy to maneuver while cooking. Over the years, these skillets have developed a sought-after patina that only enhances their appeal. Many collectors treasure these older pieces for both their utility and their historical significance.

Rare Birmingham Stove and Range No.10 Pan

The Birmingham Stove and Range No.10 skillet, made in the 1930s, is highly regarded by collectors due to its high-quality craftsmanship and vintage appeal. The cast is clearly on the bottom of the pan, which is a reliable indicator of authenticity. The market value for this skillet typically ranges between $200 and $350 for pieces in good condition. Early, smooth-finish versions are often priced higher due to their rarity.

These skillets are known for their excellent heat retention, which allows for consistent cooking. The handle is thick and easy to grip, offering more control when handling the pan. The smooth interior allows for easy cooking and cleaning, while the clear markings add to its collectibility. Collectors prize this piece for its durability, design, and cooking performance.

Griswold Erie No.9 Skillet with Slant Logo

The Griswold Erie No.9 skillet, released around 1910, is one of the most sought-after pieces from the Griswold foundry. The slant logo, with the letters angled across the pan’s base, is a distinct feature that helps collectors identify it. Depending on the condition, these skillets can range in value from $180 to $350. Pieces with a smooth surface and crisp logo often fetch the highest prices.

This skillet is known for its superior heat distribution, which makes it perfect for frying, searing, and baking. The handle is well-designed, with a comfortable grip that allows for easy lifting and handling. The smooth interior is highly prized, as it makes for a non-stick surface that enhances the cooking experience. Many collectors view this skillet not only as a useful kitchen tool but as an important historical item.

Griswold Erie No.5 Skillet

This smaller cast-iron skillet was produced in the early 1900s and is often sought after by collectors due to its compact size and rare logo. The Erie name is stamped clearly on the base, making it easy to identify. These skillets are typically valued between $90 and $200, depending on the condition and clarity of the logo. Pieces with a smooth interior and well-preserved surface are more likely to fetch higher prices.

This skillet’s small size makes it ideal for single servings or small frying tasks. The handle is short and easy to grip, which makes it particularly handy for smaller portions. Many collectors prefer the early Erie skillets for their quality craftsmanship and smooth cooking surface. Its age and design make it a valuable piece in any cast-iron collection.

Piqua Favorite Cast Iron Pan

The Piqua Favorite skillet, made in the early 1900s, features a simple logo with the word Favorite cast in block letters. This design makes it easy to spot and identify for collectors. The market price for these skillets typically ranges from $60 to $150, though well-preserved pieces with clear markings can go for more. The smooth cooking surface and solid construction are key factors that contribute to their value.

The skillet is smaller in size but still offers great heat retention, making it suitable for everyday cooking. Its compact design allows for easy maneuvering and storage. Many collectors enjoy the rustic charm of the Piqua Favorite due to its age and unique markings. It remains a popular choice for both practical use and display in cast iron collections.

Finex Cast Iron Skillet with Octagon Shape

The Finex Cast Iron skillet is a more modern piece, introduced in the 2000s with a unique octagon shape. This design sets it apart from traditional round skillets and is one of its most recognizable features. Market prices for a well-maintained example are between $100 and $180. The unusual shape contributes to its even heat distribution and makes it a standout piece in the kitchen.

The octagonal design helps provide more surface area for cooking and gives it a modern look. The heavy-duty handle allows for easy lifting, while the multiple grip options ensure better control. This skillet combines the best features of old-fashioned cast iron with a sleek, contemporary design. It is appreciated by both collectors and cooks for its functionality and aesthetic appeal.

Favorite Cast Iron No.9 Pan

The Collector’s Favorite Cast Iron No.9 skillet, made around the 1890s, is highly sought after for its simple yet effective design. The block-letter logo with a border gives it a classic, vintage look. Prices for these skillets typically range from $80 to $210, depending on their condition. Smooth interiors with well-preserved markings are particularly valuable.

This skillet is the perfect size for cooking a variety of dishes, from eggs to steaks. Its heavy construction ensures it retains heat well, making it ideal for searing or slow-cooking. Some collectors seek out this particular pan due to the rarity of its clear markings. Its blend of functionality and history makes it a valuable addition to any cast iron collection.

Griswold Slant Logo Erie No.10 Skillet

Released around 1915, the Griswold Slant Logo No.10 skillet features a slanted cross and company name, making it easily identifiable for collectors. The sharp logo and even cooking surface are the defining characteristics of this popular pan. Current market prices for these skillets range from $190 to $330. Well-maintained versions with smooth interiors and visible markings are worth more.

These skillets are prized for their large surface area, which is perfect for frying or baking. The heavy-duty handle provides a comfortable and secure grip during cooking. The slanted logo gives the skillet a distinctive look, and its quality craftsmanship ensures consistent results on the stove. Collectors often look for these pieces due to their aesthetic appeal and historical value.

This article originally appeared on Avocadu.