15 Rare Makeup Collabs That Now Resell For More Than Retail

This post may contain affiliate links, which helps keep this content free. Please read our disclosure for more info.

MAC x Rihanna RiRi Hearts MAC Collection

This MAC and Rihanna run still gets talked about because the colors felt like they belonged in a real makeup bag, not just a display shelf. The red lip shades and warm bronzy tones photographed well and looked good in everyday light. Packaging with Rihanna’s signature touch made it feel personal, which is part of why people kept their pieces sealed. Even now, a clean set can pull serious resale prices when it pops up.

Some buyers want it for the nostalgia, while others want the exact lip colors that became instant staples. A lot of listings focus on unused items, since collectors like the original finish and box. If you are buying secondhand, pay attention to batch codes and close-up photos of the bullet and cap. It helps to compare multiple listings because condition and completeness change the price fast.

MAC x Selena Quintanilla Collection

This collaboration hit an emotional note for many fans, and that alone pushed demand high. The packaging leaned into Selena’s style and made the products feel like keepsakes. Shades were chosen to match her looks, so it felt like a tribute you could actually wear. That combination kept it from sitting around for long at retail.

Resale is often highest for full sets, especially when the outer boxes are included. Individual lipsticks and palettes still move quickly when they are in good shape. People also buy it as a gift, which keeps the market active year after year. If you see a listing with scuffed packaging, the price can drop a lot even if the product is unused.

Urban Decay x Gwen Stefani Collection

This release landed right in the sweet spot for anyone who loves classic glam with a pop star edge. The eyeshadow palette had wearable neutrals plus a few brighter shades that felt very Gwen. Packaging looked sleek and collectible without being fussy. It sold out fast in many places, which helped fuel the resale buzz.

Buyers still look for the palette, the red lipstick shades, and the highlighter because they match that era perfectly. Some people want it for the formulas, while others want it for the memory of the launch. Secondhand prices swing based on whether the mirror and palette surface are clean. Photos matter here, since scratches and powder kick-up can change the value.

Pat McGrath Labs x Supreme Lipstick

This one lives at the intersection of makeup and streetwear, so it attracts two different types of shoppers. Supreme’s limited drops already create a rush, and adding Pat McGrath made it even more desirable. The red lipstick became the main target because it was easy to display and easy to sell. That mix is why it can resell well above retail.

Many listings focus on the full packaging and any included extras, since collectors want everything intact. Some buyers never even open it, which keeps unopened units in circulation at higher prices. If you do want to wear it, check for clear photos of the seal and the tube. The safest buys usually come from sellers who show multiple angles and original proof of purchase.

NARS x Christopher Kane Collection

This collaboration stood out because it looked fashion-forward without feeling like costume makeup. The color story leaned modern, with punchy lips and cheek tones that were still wearable. The packaging had that designer feel that makes people want to keep it on a vanity. Limited availability helped it turn into a resale favorite.

Certain shades are harder to find now, especially if they were popular on social media at launch. People also like full sets because the collection feels cohesive when you have more than one item. Condition is a big deal since NARS packaging can pick up scratches and fingerprints. A clean compact or lipstick tube often sells for more than you would expect years later.

NARS x Pierre Hardy Collection

Fans loved this one for the graphic packaging as much as the products inside. The bold geometric design made the compacts look like little art pieces. Color choices were playful, with cheek shades that worked for both soft and statement looks. Once stock disappeared, resale started creeping upward.

Collectors tend to chase the blushes and the eye palettes because they show off the packaging best. Some buyers display them rather than use them, which keeps demand high for untouched items. If you are buying used, ask for close-ups of the powder surface and the hinge. A cracked shade or loose pan can turn a good deal into a regret.

Too Faced x Kat Von D Collaboration Set

This older collaboration feels like a time capsule from a very specific makeup era. It had an edgy-meets-sweet vibe that stood out on shelves and online photos. The set is not as easy to find now, which keeps it interesting to collectors. When a complete set appears, it can move quickly.

People who collect early influencer-era releases often look for this collab to fill a gap in their stash. Packaging condition matters a lot because sets like this often got tossed around in drawers. Look for listings that show the inside clearly, not just the closed exterior. If the seller has the original box and inserts, the price usually jumps.

ColourPop x Disney Disney Designer Collection

This was a big moment for ColourPop because it felt like a true event launch. The designer theme pulled in Disney fans who do not even follow makeup closely. Each princess-inspired shade story made it easy to pick a favorite, and many people wanted the whole set. That kind of demand is a recipe for resale over retail.

Full collections often sell for more, especially when all the components match and nothing is missing. Individual items still resell, but they usually go fastest when they are still sealed. Since ColourPop packaging can scuff, photos of the corners and lids are useful. Even small dings can knock the price down more than you would think.

ColourPop x Disney Midnight Masquerade Collection

This collection became a collector favorite because the packaging looked like a display item. The dolls and masks theme made the compacts feel special, almost like little collectibles from a theme park shop. Products were also limited, which pushed fans to buy quickly. Once it sold out, the resale market stayed active.

People tend to chase the full set, but certain character compacts can be especially hard to find. Buyers care about the outer box and inserts because they make the set feel complete. If you are shopping secondhand, watch for dents and peeling on the compact artwork. A mint-condition compact can cost much more than one with worn edges.

ColourPop x Disney Villains Collection

Villain releases always bring a lot of excitement, and this one leaned into that energy. The color story had deeper tones and metallics that felt fun for nights out and costume season. Packaging was themed enough to feel collectible, yet still usable day to day. That mix helped it hold value on resale.

Collectors often look for the full vault or the most popular villain shades. Sets in their original packaging tend to command higher prices because they look gift-ready. If an item is used, buyers usually want clear photos of pans and lipstick tips. Small signs of wear can change what people are willing to pay.

Besame Cosmetics x Disney Snow White Collection

Besame is known for vintage-inspired styling, so pairing it with Snow White felt like a natural match. The packaging looked like it belonged in an old movie prop room, in a good way. Items were also very giftable, which means some were bought to save rather than use. That keeps unopened pieces circulating at higher resale prices.

Collectors often hunt for the mirror compact, the lip products, and any limited accessories from the launch. Condition is huge because a scuffed compact loses that fairytale look fast. If you want a display-worthy piece, look for listings that show the finish in bright light. A complete set with box often sells for more than separate items added up.

Besame Cosmetics x Disney Sleeping Beauty Collection

This collab leaned into storybook styling with soft colors and elegant details. It felt like a collector item, but the shades were still wearable for day-to-day looks. Besame fans also tend to keep packaging, which makes complete sets harder to find later. That scarcity helps resale stay strong.

The compact and lip products are the most sought-after pieces, especially when they still have the original box. Many buyers want it for display, so scratches and worn printing can be deal breakers. If you plan to actually use it, check seller notes for storage conditions and any scent changes. Clean photos and honest descriptions are the best signs of a safe purchase.

Anastasia Beverly Hills x Amrezy Highlighter

This highlighter became a legend because it gave a strong glow without looking chalky on many skin tones. People loved the smooth texture and the way it caught light in photos. It also had a long wait between restocks, which kept demand high for years. Even now, it can resell for more than retail when it is in good condition.

Buyers usually want one that is barely touched, since highlighters show brush marks quickly. Some sellers list it as a collector item, especially if the compact is clean and the lettering is intact. If you are shopping secondhand, look closely for hard pan or a dull surface. A well-kept compact with the box often pulls the best price.

Jeffree Star Cosmetics x Manny MUA Collaboration

This collab sits in a very specific moment in beauty history, which is part of why it gets collector attention. Fans who followed that era like owning the piece of makeup drama and internet nostalgia. The packaging and shade choices were distinct enough to stand out from regular releases. It is not easy to find complete sets now, which pushes resale up.

Collectors often look for unused items, since older liquid formulas can change over time. If you are buying to use, be cautious and check photos for separation, texture changes, or dried product. Sellers who show swatch-free applicators and clean components tend to get more interest. A full set with original packaging is usually the most expensive option.

MAC x Disney Villains Collection

This MAC collab became a collector staple because the villain theme was strong and the packaging felt like a limited souvenir. The color range was fun, with dramatic lips and smoky eye options that suited the concept. Many people bought multiples, either to keep one sealed or to trade later. That behavior helped keep resale prices higher than retail for certain pieces.

The most chased items often include the lipsticks and the compacts with the most striking artwork. Buyers also pay extra for complete sets because the collection looks great together. If you are shopping secondhand, make sure the shade name labels are readable and the caps close tightly. Small details like that can signal whether the item was stored carefully.