15 Mystery Audiobooks with Narrators You Can’t Fully Trust

If you love a good mystery, you know that sometimes the most thrilling part of a story is not just the crime but the narrator guiding you through it. In these audiobooks, the line between truth and deception becomes blurred, and the characters themselves often lead you down a twisting path of uncertainty. The narrators in these stories may seem reliable at first, but as the plot unfolds, you start to question whether their accounts can be trusted. Whether it’s through hidden motives, unreliable memories, or distorted perspectives, these audiobooks keep you guessing. Each turn in the story builds suspense, making it hard to know what’s real and what’s fabricated.

This post may contain affiliate links, which helps keep this content free. Please read our disclosure for more info.

The Woman in the Window by A.J. Finn

The audiobook The Woman in the Window continues to captivate listeners with its portrayal of Anna Fox’s unreliable perception of reality. Narrated by Ann Marie Lee, the experience is filled with suspense and unsettling twists. Anna’s agoraphobia and self-inflicted isolation blur the lines between truth and paranoia, forcing listeners to decide whether the crime she believes she witnessed is real or a creation of her mind.

Lee’s skillful performance enhances the tension, making Anna’s fractured state feel tangible. As the story progresses, the suspense intensifies, keeping the audience on edge. The book’s narrative builds toward a conclusion that challenges everything the listener thought they knew.

Sharp Objects by Gillian Flynn

Gillian Flynn’s Sharp Objects is a haunting psychological thriller featuring Camille Preaker, a reporter who returns to her hometown to cover the murder of two young girls. The audiobook, narrated by Ann Marie Lee, brings Camille’s dark past and troubled present to life. As Camille struggles with her demons and attempts to uncover the truth about the murders, the listener is forced to confront the ambiguity of her own narrative.

The unreliable nature of Camille’s recollections creates a sense of unease, as her emotional struggles make her less than trustworthy. Lee’s narration reflects the tension and psychological depth of the story, keeping the listener questioning both Camille’s version of events and her mental state. The eerie atmosphere of the small-town setting is brought to life through Lee’s evocative delivery, which amplifies the twisted nature of the mystery.

The Night Listener by Armistead Maupin

The Night Listener by Armistead Maupin explores the mystery of a radio show host, Gabriel Noone, who begins receiving letters from a young boy named Peter, whose life seems to be shrouded in mystery. The audiobook, narrated by the author himself, blurs the lines between fiction and reality, drawing listeners into a story where the truth seems ever-shifting. As Gabriel attempts to uncover the truth about Peter’s background, he is faced with his own unreliable emotions and interpretations of events.

Maupin’s voice delivery adds a layer of authenticity, but it also introduces doubt, as Gabriel’s fixation on the boy grows more obsessive. The psychological tension is elevated as secrets and lies unfold, forcing the audience to constantly reevaluate the narrative. With themes of deception and manipulation, this audiobook keeps the listener captivated as it explores the limits of trust.

Big Little Lies by Liane Moriarty

Liane Moriarty’s Big Little Lies is a compelling mystery that focuses on the lives of three women, each of whom harbors their own secrets and lies. The audiobook features a full cast, and Caroline Lee’s narration of the characters’ perspectives brings out the tension and drama of the story. As the mystery unfolds, listeners are presented with conflicting narratives from each woman, making it difficult to trust anyone’s account.

Lee’s narration highlights the complexity of the relationships and the secrets buried beneath the surface. The unreliable narrators keep the audience guessing, unsure of what is truth and what is a carefully constructed lie. The escalating tension, combined with Lee’s vivid portrayal of the characters, creates a sense of unease that carries throughout the book.

Behind Closed Doors by B.A. Paris

In Behind Closed Doors, B.A. Paris explores the seemingly perfect marriage between Jack and Grace Angel, which hides a dark and twisted reality. Narrated by Georgia Maguire, the audiobook immerses listeners in the horrifying dynamic of the couple’s life behind closed doors. Grace, who appears to have everything, is revealed to be trapped in a manipulative and abusive relationship, but her story is clouded by her own struggles to maintain a façade of normalcy.

Maguire’s narration captures Grace’s fear and helplessness, while also portraying Jack’s disturbing control over his wife. The contrast between what appears to be a loving relationship and the sinister reality adds an unsettling layer of complexity to the narrative. As the story unfolds, listeners must question what they know about the couple and whether they can trust Grace’s account of events.

The Couple Next Door by Shari Lapena

Shari Lapena’s The Couple Next Door presents a mystery involving the disappearance of a baby while the parents attend a dinner party next door. The audiobook, narrated by various voices, offers a mix of unreliable perspectives, particularly from Anne, the mother, whose memory and perception of events become increasingly questionable.

The tension grows as Anne and Marco, the parents, provide conflicting accounts of the night their child went missing. With each passing chapter, the listener is left questioning whether the couple is hiding something, or if the truth lies somewhere in between. The layered storytelling and unreliable narration keep the audience engaged, as they try to unravel the mystery behind the child’s disappearance.

The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo by Stieg Larsson

The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo is a gripping thriller that follows journalist Mikael Blomkvist and hacker Lisbeth Salander as they investigate the disappearance of a young woman from a powerful family. The audiobook, narrated by Simon Vance, introduces a complex web of deception and corruption, where the characters themselves are not entirely trustworthy.

Blomkvist’s journalistic integrity is called into question, and Lisbeth’s past is shrouded in mystery. Vance’s narration brings both characters to life with precision, but their perspectives often leave the listener unsure of who can be trusted. As they uncover hidden secrets, the story becomes more intricate, and the tension mounts.

The Silent Patient by Alex Michaelides

Alex Michaelides’ The Silent Patient is a psychological thriller that centers around Alicia Berenson, a woman who shoots her husband and then chooses not to speak again. The audiobook, narrated by Jack Hawkins, is told through the perspective of Theo Faber, a forensic psychologist who becomes obsessed with understanding Alicia’s silence.

As Theo investigates her past, his own biases and emotional involvement with the case make him a potentially unreliable narrator. Hawkins’ narration reflects the growing tension and emotional turmoil as Theo tries to uncover the truth. The shifts in perspective throughout the story keep the listener questioning Theo’s motivations and the truth behind Alicia’s silence.

The Secret History by Donna Tartt

The Secret History by Donna Tartt is a gripping novel about a group of college students whose lives are changed forever after a murder. The audiobook, narrated by Will Damron, presents the story through the unreliable eyes of Richard Papen, who becomes entangled in a world of intellectual obsession and moral decay.

As Richard becomes involved with the group, the line between loyalty and morality begins to blur, and his own perceptions of the events surrounding the murder become distorted. Damron’s delivery captures Richard’s internal conflict and confusion, making him a compelling but unreliable narrator. The psychological tension builds as secrets and lies are uncovered, keeping the audience on edge.

I Am Watching You by Teresa Driscoll

I Am Watching You by Teresa Driscoll is a mystery about a missing person, told from multiple unreliable perspectives. The audiobook features a full cast, with each character offering their version of events that gradually weave together to uncover the truth. The unreliable nature of the characters’ accounts forces the listener to question everything they hear.

The alternating perspectives keep the suspense high as secrets are revealed and the true nature of the disappearance is slowly unraveled. The full cast’s performance heightens the tension, as each character’s motives and hidden agendas come to light.

The Girl on the Train by Paula Hawkins

In The Girl on the Train, the main character, Rachel, embarks on a journey of self-discovery and suspicion after witnessing what she believes is a crime. The audiobook’s narrator, Clare Corbett, captures Rachel’s emotional instability and fragmented memory, but listeners are left questioning her reliability. As the story unfolds, the listener is unsure whether Rachel’s perception of events is clouded by alcohol, personal trauma, or if she truly is witnessing something sinister. Corbett’s voice fluctuates between vulnerability and uncertainty, which keeps listeners on edge.

The unreliable narration challenges the audience to dissect each clue critically. The layers of deception in Rachel’s narrative create a compelling atmosphere of doubt, leading to unexpected twists and turns. This mystery audiobook plays with the notion of trust, forcing listeners to question everything they hear. Every chapter feels like a new revelation, with Corbett’s delivery highlighting the inner turmoil that makes Rachel such a fascinating yet unreliable character.

Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn

Gillian Flynn’s Gone Girl is a gripping psychological thriller that keeps readers guessing with its unreliable narrators. The audiobook features two narrators, Julia Whelan and Kirby Heyborne, who bring the characters of Nick and Amy to life. Amy, in particular, is a master of deception, and Whelan’s performance gives her an eerie charm that makes it difficult to fully trust her perspective. As Amy recounts her version of events, it’s clear that her storytelling is not just manipulative, but deliberately constructed to mislead Nick and the listener.

Meanwhile, Nick’s narration, performed by Kirby Heyborne, offers his version of their troubled marriage, but his words, too, are fraught with ambiguity. The alternating perspectives from the two narrators create a sense of unease, leaving listeners questioning their motives and the truth behind the crime. Both Whelan and Heyborne’s performances heighten the tension, making Gone Girl a captivating experience where trust is consistently undermined.

Shutter Island by Dennis Lehane

Dennis Lehane’s Shutter Island is a dark and atmospheric mystery that follows U.S. Marshal Teddy Daniels as he investigates the disappearance of a patient from a mental institution. The audiobook is narrated by Tom Stechschulte, who expertly conveys the confusion and tension Daniels experiences. As Daniels delves deeper into the mystery, the line between reality and delusion begins to blur, making him an unreliable narrator. Stechschulte’s performance keeps listeners questioning Daniels’ perceptions, as his unraveling mind creates a sense of dread.

The twists and turns in Shutter Island force the listener to challenge every assumption they make about the story. Stechschulte’s delivery of Daniels’ internal struggle enhances the psychological tension, leaving listeners unsure of whether the investigation is real or a figment of Daniels’ fractured mind. This audiobook makes for an immersive experience where every revelation leaves you second-guessing the truth.

Before I Go to Sleep by S.J. Watson

Before I Go to Sleep by S.J. Watson follows Christine Lucas, a woman who suffers from amnesia and wakes up each day with no memory of her past. The audiobook, narrated by Orlagh Cassidy, captures the disorienting experience Christine faces as she tries to piece together her life. Each day, Christine relies on her journal to recount her memories, but her trust in those memories begins to waver as she uncovers disturbing truths. Cassidy’s narration reflects Christine’s growing anxiety and uncertainty, making it challenging for listeners to determine what is real and what is a product of her fractured memory.

As Christine learns that her husband may not be who he seems, the suspense builds, and the listener is left questioning whether Christine can trust anyone, including herself. Lee’s emotional range adds depth to the experience, further emphasizing the blurred lines between memory and reality. Cassidy’s emotional range adds depth to the experience, further emphasizing the blurred lines between memory and reality.

The Girl with a Clock for a Heart by Peter Swanson

Peter Swanson’s The Girl with a Clock for a Heart is a mystery that takes listeners on a fast-paced journey through a man’s past and present. The audiobook is narrated by the talented Michael Crouch, whose portrayal of George Foss provides insight into a character torn between loyalty and suspicion. George’s former lover, Liana, reappears in his life, dragging him back into a dangerous world of deception and crime.

Crouch’s delivery enhances the ambiguity surrounding Liana’s true intentions, making her an enigmatic and unreliable character in George’s life. As George navigates a series of high-stakes decisions, the listener is left questioning his trust in both Liana and his own judgment. The story is filled with unexpected twists that make every character’s actions feel suspect. Crouch’s narration keeps the tension high, ensuring that every moment is filled with uncertainty and suspense.

This article originally appeared on Avocadu.