14 Christmas Records People Still Play and Collect
Christmas records hold a special place in many homes, evoking warm memories and festive cheer each holiday season. Whether it’s the soothing sounds of a classic crooner or the lively rhythm of a timeless rock band, these albums have a way of bringing the holiday spirit to life. As the years go by, certain albums remain favorites, still spun on turntables, cherished by collectors and music lovers alike. From the iconic melodies of Bing Crosby to the soulful renditions by Nat King Cole, these records carry a sense of nostalgia and joy that never fades.
This post may contain affiliate links, which helps keep this content free. Please read our disclosure for more info.
Bing Crosby – Merry Christmas
Bing Crosby’s Merry Christmas is more than just an album; it’s a timeless holiday tradition. Released in 1942, this album is home to the record-breaking song “White Christmas,” which has been a holiday favorite for decades. Crosby’s smooth, baritone voice and classic renditions of songs like “Silent Night” and “God Rest Ye Merry, Gentlemen” set a nostalgic mood that’s perfect for the holiday season.
For collectors, a first pressing of this album in excellent condition can be a rare find, adding to its value. The historical significance of Crosby’s contribution to Christmas music makes this album not just a collector’s item, but a piece of musical history. In good condition, this album can be worth around $50, with earlier pressings often fetching higher prices due to their rarity.
Nat King Cole – The Christmas Song
Nat King Cole’s The Christmas Song has become synonymous with holiday cheer. Released in 1960, it features Cole’s velvety voice on some of the most iconic Christmas songs, including the beloved “The Christmas Song” (Chestnuts Roasting on an Open Fire). His smooth, sophisticated delivery of traditional Christmas tunes adds a touch of elegance to any holiday gathering.
The album’s combination of familiar melodies and Cole’s unmatched vocal style has made it a favorite for generations. Vinyl collectors seek out original pressings of this album, especially the early Capitol records releases. A near-mint copy of The Christmas Song can be valued between $30 and $50, depending on its condition and pressing.
Elvis Presley – Elvis’ Christmas
First released in 1957, Elvis’ Christmas Album is a standout in Presley’s catalog and a beloved holiday classic. Featuring his unmistakable voice, the album includes both traditional carols like “Silent Night” and “Blue Christmas,” as well as original songs that became instant holiday favorites.
The album’s popularity has only grown over the years, as it brings together the best of rock and roll with the timeless spirit of Christmas. Collectors of Elvis Presley memorabilia often seek out original pressings, which can be worth between $50 and $80 depending on the condition and rarity of the pressing.
A Charlie Brown Christmas Soundtrack – Vince Guaraldi Trio
Vince Guaraldi’s A Charlie Brown Christmas soundtrack is a soothing, jazzy celebration of the holiday season. Released in 1965, the album features beautiful piano compositions that have become just as synonymous with Christmas as the Peanuts TV special itself. The opening track, “Christmas Time Is Here,” is one of the most recognizable holiday tunes, with its soft, calming melody that evokes the essence of the season.
Guaraldi’s mastery of jazz and his ability to create a mood of both simplicity and warmth make this album a timeless classic. For vinyl collectors, the first pressing of this album is a prized find due to its rarity and the cultural significance of the Peanuts special. Depending on its condition, the album can fetch $50 to $70 for an original pressing.
The Beach Boys – The Beach Boys’ Christmas
Released in 1964, The Beach Boys’ Christmas Album brings the unique sound of California surf rock to the Christmas season. Featuring upbeat, harmonious renditions of classic Christmas songs like “Little Saint Nick” and “Santa’s Beard,” the album captures the youthful energy and sunny spirit of the Beach Boys.
The album’s playful vibe and the group’s cheerful style have made it a lasting holiday favorite. Collectors of Beach Boys memorabilia often seek out first pressings of this album, which can be valued between $40 and $60. Its iconic cover art and the band’s influence on pop music culture further increase its desirability.
Frank Sinatra – A Jolly Christmas from Frank Sinatra
Frank Sinatra’s A Jolly Christmas from Frank Sinatra, released in 1957, remains one of the most popular holiday albums ever recorded. With his smooth, warm voice, Sinatra brings a sense of class and elegance to Christmas standards like “Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas” and “Jingle Bells.”
Vinyl collectors seek out original pressings of this album, with copies in excellent condition often valued between $30 and $50. Sinatra’s enduring legacy in the world of jazz and pop music only adds to the album’s appeal. For those who appreciate the classics, this album is an essential piece of holiday music history.
Mahalia Jackson – The Essential Mahalia Jackson Christmas
Mahalia Jackson’s The Essential Mahalia Jackson Christmas album, released in the 1960s, offers a deeply moving and soulful collection of Christmas classics. Known for her powerful gospel voice, Jackson brings a sense of reverence and emotion to every track, transforming holiday standards like “Silent Night” and “O Holy Night” into stirring performances.
First pressings of The Essential Mahalia Jackson Christmas can be found for $40 to $60, depending on condition. This album’s blend of gospel music and Christmas tradition has made it a favorite for both holiday music lovers and collectors of religious music.
Perry Como – Perry Como’s Christmas
Perry Como’s Christmas Album, released in 1959, is a quintessential example of smooth, easy-listening Christmas music. Known for his relaxed vocal style, Como’s renditions of songs like “There Is No Christmas Like a Home Christmas” and “Winter Wonderland” exude a sense of comfort and warmth.
Original pressings of Perry Como’s Christmas Album are valued at $30 to $50, with mint condition copies fetching higher prices. This album’s timeless appeal and Como’s iconic voice make it a treasured part of Christmas music history. Its smooth, festive sound ensures it remains a holiday favorite year after year.
Ray Conniff Singers – We Wish You a Merry Christmas
The Ray Conniff Singers’ We Wish You a Merry Christmas, released in 1962, offers an upbeat and harmonious collection of holiday tunes. Known for their lush vocal harmonies and cheerful arrangements, the Ray Conniff Singers breathe new life into Christmas classics like “Jingle Bells” and “Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer.”
A first pressing can range in value from $25 to $40, depending on the condition of the record. The album’s vibrant energy, combined with the Singers’ vocal talent, makes it an enduring favorite for anyone looking to add a little more cheer to their holiday playlist.
Burl Ives – Have a Holly Jolly Christmas
Released in 1965, Burl Ives’ Have a Holly Jolly Christmas is a warm and lively holiday album that has become a Christmas staple. Known for his rich voice and folk-style delivery, Ives brings a joyful, homespun quality to songs like “Holly Jolly Christmas” and “Silver Bells.”
The album’s iconic title track has remained one of the most enduring holiday songs ever since its release. For collectors, original pressings of Have a Holly Jolly Christmas are highly prized, with first pressings typically valued between $30 and $50. This album’s combination of nostalgic charm and lively performances ensures that it remains a go-to choice for holiday music enthusiasts.
Johnny Cash – The Christmas Spirit
Johnny Cash’s The Christmas Spirit, released in 1963, is a distinctive holiday album that blends Cash’s deep, resonant voice with traditional Christmas songs. Known for his country and gospel influences, Cash offers a fresh, heartfelt take on holiday classics like “The Little Drummer Boy” and “Blue Christmas.”
Collectors value original pressings of The Christmas Spirit, with copies in good condition often fetching $30 to $50. The album’s combination of country music and holiday spirit makes it a unique addition to any Christmas collection. For those who appreciate the timeless quality of Cash’s voice, this album is a cherished piece of holiday music history.
James Brown – A James Brown Christmas
First released in 1966, A James Brown Christmas blends the legendary funk of James Brown with the warmth of holiday music. Known for his electrifying performances and funky grooves, Brown brings a fresh, high-energy take on Christmas classics like “Santa Claus Go Straight to the Ghetto” and “Let’s Make Christmas Mean Something This Year.”
The combination of funk and Christmas music offers a unique listening experience that has made the album a fan favorite. For collectors, A James Brown Christmas is a valuable find, with first pressings generally valued at $50 to $80. The album’s unique blend of funk and holiday spirit ensures that it remains a sought-after item for vinyl enthusiasts.
Dean Martin – Dean Martin Christmas
Released in 1966, Dean Martin Christmas is a holiday album that perfectly captures the charm and laid-back style of the crooner. Known for his relaxed vocal delivery, Martin’s renditions of “Let It Snow! Let It Snow! Let It Snow!” and “Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer” bring a sense of warmth and joy to the Christmas season.
Vinyl collectors seek out original pressings of this album, particularly those with unique cover art or rare pressings. A well-maintained first pressing of Dean Martin Christmas can be valued between $25 and $40, depending on condition. Martin’s voice and the album’s easy-listening style have made it a favorite for casual holiday music lovers.
The Jackson 5 – Jackson 5 Christmas
The Jackson 5’s Jackson 5 Christmas Album, released in 1970, is a soulful, energetic take on traditional Christmas songs. With Michael Jackson’s youthful voice fronting the group, this album features fun, funky renditions of classics like “I Saw Mommy Kissing Santa Claus” and “Santa Claus Is Coming to Town.”
Depending on condition, a first pressing can fetch between $50 and $80, making it a sought-after find for vinyl collectors. The album’s upbeat energy and the Jackson 5’s unique sound make it a must-have for fans of both soul music and Christmas classics. This album’s lasting popularity has cemented it as an essential part of any Christmas vinyl collection.
This article originally appeared on Avocadu.