13 Vintage Halloween Buckets Worth Surprisingly High Prices

This post may contain affiliate links, which helps keep this content free. Please read our disclosure for more info.

Vintage McDonald’s Halloween McBoo Bucket 1986

The 1986 McBoo bucket is a favorite among collectors because it represents the first generation of McDonald’s Halloween pails. Many people love the simple ghost design that feels playful and nostalgic. This bucket is often remembered fondly since families used it for trick or treating and storage long after the holiday season.

The lightweight plastic has held up surprisingly well, which makes surviving pieces even more appealing. Collectors enjoy finding versions with crisp graphics that have not faded. Because of the bucket’s history and wide fan base, the value has increased steadily through the years. A clean example can reach around $45 to $75 depending on condition.

General Foam Plastics Pumpkin Pail 1970s

This older pumpkin pail from the 1970s has a distinctive molded look that sets it apart from newer versions. Many collectors appreciate the thicker plastic that feels sturdier than later designs. The exaggerated smile and deep grooves add character that fits well with vintage Halloween décor. Some versions even show slight imperfections from the molding process that make each piece feel unique.

These pails were widely used by children during trick or treat nights, which means many existing pieces show signs of wear. Collectors look for clean edges, strong color, and no warping. A well cared for piece can bring $60 to $120.

Empire Plastics Pumpkin Bucket 1980s

Empire Plastics produced many seasonal items, and this pumpkin bucket from the 1980s remains one of its most recognizable pieces. The bold orange shade and carved style face help it stand out in a collection. Many people remember carrying this bucket because it was lightweight and roomy enough for candy.

The brand has a loyal following, which raises buyer interest in cleaner pieces. Some versions feature a slightly different shape depending on the production year, so collectors enjoy comparing variants. This bucket often serves as a nostalgic reminder of neighborhood trick or treating. A solid example can sell for $45 to $90.

Tupperware Pumpkin Keeper 1970s

This pumpkin keeper was originally sold as a storage container, but families often used it as a Halloween treat bucket. The durable Tupperware plastic has kept many surviving pieces in good condition. Collectors enjoy the rounded shape and smooth finish that set it apart from the more common trick or treat pails.

This item is often found with minor scratches due to long term use, but well preserved examples remain attractive. Many collectors remember this piece as part of seasonal family traditions. Its unique style makes it a fun display item during the fall months. Current prices range from $35 to $70.

Ohio Art Tin Trick or Treat Bucket 1960s

These tin buckets from the 1960s hold special appeal because they were produced before plastic pails became widespread. The bright lithographed designs show playful Halloween scenes that reflect the style of the decade. Many surviving pieces show scratches due to the softer metal material, yet these marks often add charm.

Collectors especially enjoy versions with vivid color and minimal rust. Because fewer examples have survived, interest continues to rise among vintage buyers. The lightweight metal construction makes it an eye-catching display piece. Well preserved Ohio Art buckets can reach $150 to $250.

Vintage Disney Mickey Pumpkin Bucket 1990s

This Mickey themed pumpkin pail became popular during the rise of themed merchandise at major theme parks. The smiling Mickey face molded into the pumpkin creates a fun crossover between Halloween and Disney collecting. Many families kept these buckets as souvenirs, which raised sentimental value.

The bright plastic has held up well, though some pieces show light fading from sun exposure. Collectors enjoy finding versions that include original park tags. Because it appeals to both Disney collectors and vintage seasonal collectors, demand has grown steadily. Market value usually ranges from $40 to $85.

Vintage Don Post Pumpkin Bucket 1970s

This pumpkin bucket from Don Post carries charm because it connects to a company known for memorable Halloween masks. The bucket features deeper sculpting than many plastic pails of the era, giving it a look that stands out on a shelf. Collectors enjoy the expressive face that reflects the playful spirit of the season.

Many families used these buckets for years, which means well preserved pieces are prized. Some examples show light wear, yet the overall appearance remains appealing. Interest continues to grow as more collectors focus on older Halloween items. Current values often range from $75 to $140.

Vintage Peanuts Snoopy Halloween Bucket 1990s

This bucket celebrates Snoopy in his seasonal attire, which brings together fans of vintage Halloween items and Peanuts collectors. The bright colors hold up well to age, making these buckets cheerful display pieces. Families often kept these as souvenirs from themed promotions, which increased the survival rate.

Some pieces may show light scratches, but many still retain a crisp appearance. Collectors enjoy the happy expression that fits perfectly with the character’s charm. The bucket remains a favorite among fans who enjoy character themed décor. Values typically land between $45 and $85.

Vintage Eerie Witch Plastic Bucket 1970s

This vintage witch bucket has a distinctive green face that creates a memorable visual. The exaggerated features reflect the Halloween style of the decade, which collectors enjoy for its playful charm. These buckets were commonly found in drugstores and discount shops, so many people remember them vividly from childhood.

Because the plastic was somewhat softer than other brands, scratches and small dents are common. Well cared for items with strong color attract the most attention. The bucket adds personality to any seasonal setup. A good example can reach $60 to $110.

Vintage Ceramic Pumpkin Pail 1970s

This ceramic pumpkin pail is far older than typical plastic versions and carries a decorative quality that collectors value. The hand painted details show charming imperfections that make each piece feel unique.

Many families displayed these in windows or on tables rather than using them for candy, which helped preserve some pieces. Because ceramic can chip easily, surviving examples without damage are highly desired. Collectors enjoy the warm glow these pieces bring when placed near soft lighting. The midcentury style makes it an appealing display item for fall décor. Values can reach $150 to $300.

Vintage Witch Cauldron Bucket 1980s

This small black cauldron shaped bucket was a favorite among children who enjoyed the spooky theme. The round shape and textured surface give it a fun look that works well with seasonal décor. Many families reused these buckets for years, which means many surviving examples show light wear.

Collectors prefer buckets with strong handles and minimal dents. Some versions feature slightly different plastic thicknesses depending on production runs, which makes collecting variations enjoyable. The playful design makes it a charming piece for Halloween fans. Typical values fall between $25 and $50.

Vintage Pumpkin Pail with Metal Handle 1950s

This early pumpkin pail holds a special place in collector circles because it predates most mass produced plastic versions. The molded paper pulp material creates a rustic, old fashioned appearance. Many families displayed these as decorations rather than using them outdoors, which helped some survive.

The metal handle adds character and often develops a slight patina that collectors appreciate. Pieces without cracks or missing sections are considered especially desirable. The vintage look pairs nicely with midcentury seasonal décor. Market value usually ranges from $120 to $220.

Vintage Ghost Bucket with Glow Feature 1990s

This ghost bucket from the 1990s was popular because it glowed after being exposed to light, creating a fun effect during nighttime trick or treating. The gentle expression makes it a playful piece that fits nicely with seasonal themes. Many families kept these buckets long after Halloween because children enjoyed the glowing feature. Some examples show light scuffs, yet the glow effect still works well in many pieces.

Collectors enjoy the simple charm that reflects the style of the decade. The glow feature adds extra appeal, especially for display shelves. Values often range from $25 to $60.

This article originally appeared on Avocadu.