12 Rare Cereal Box Promotions Worth Tracking Down

This post may contain affiliate links, which helps keep this content free. Please read our disclosure for more info.

General Mills Monster Cereal Glow Stick Inserts

These glow stick giveaways were part of a seasonal promotion that appealed to children who loved spooky themes. The glow sticks rarely survived after being opened, which makes sealed versions surprisingly rare. Unopened glow stick packets usually sit around $40.

Boxes that still show the promotional banner catch the attention of collectors. They tend to hold value for display purposes even if the glow stick inside is missing. Complete boxes with the glow stick included can reach around $100.

Cap’n Crunch Captain’s Patch Mail Away Badge

This cloth badge was part of an early promotion that allowed children to send in box proofs for a themed badge. Many kids wore the badge until it fell apart, leaving very few in good shape today. A clean badge can sell for around $75.

Unopened mail away envelopes are harder to find and can reach higher values. Items with sharp stitching and no stains attract collectors who focus on cereal related memorabilia. Full mail away sets with original paperwork may reach around $120.

Post Pebbles Flintstones Record Cutouts

Some boxes from the 1970s included cardboard records that could be played on a turntable. Since the cardboard was fragile, few records survived without damage. Playable examples can reach around $60.

Collectors prefer discs with smooth edges and minimal warping. Boxes that still have untouched punch out areas are even more desirable. A sealed box containing these records can reach around $180.

Rice Krispies Snap Crackle Pop Mini Figurines

These small figurines were included inside boxes in the early 1980s. Children often lost the pieces or damaged them during play. Single figurines in good condition usually sit around $30.

Complete sets with all three characters command higher collector interest. Original inner bags that remain sealed raise the value of the item. A sealed set can reach around $120.

Cheerios Star Wars Stickers from the 1977 Release

These stickers were part of the merchandise rush when the movie first came out. Kids used them on notebooks and lunchboxes which makes unused stickers rare today. A single unused sticker can reach around $25.

Complete sticker sheets are harder to find and can reach higher values. Boxes that feature the movie tie in artwork draw strong attention among collectors. A full sheet in clean condition may reach around $120.

Trix Rabbit 1980s Comic Book Premium

Select boxes included a small comic featuring the mascot in short adventure stories. Most comics were read heavily and eventually thrown away. Clean, unread copies can reach around $35.

Collectors enjoy complete sets from various print runs. Comics that were sealed in plastic bags carry even higher interest. A sealed comic may reach around $90 depending on condition.

Frosted Flakes Tony the Tiger Mini Spoon

This promotional spoon was designed for children and often broke after repeated use. Spoons that remain uncracked and show clear character artwork are rare and can reach around $40.

Boxes that still hold the spoon in clear plastic packaging draw strong collector interest. Items without scratches or discoloration are especially valued. A sealed spoon can reach around $80.

Honeycomb 1970s Bike License Plate Insert

Honeycomb once included small license plate inserts themed after different states. Many plates were bent or torn while being attached to bikes, which makes intact versions hard to locate. A single flat plate usually sits around $25.

Collectors enjoy full sets that represent multiple states from one release year. Plates with bright colors and no crease marks stand out during sales. Complete sets can reach around $120.

Corn Pops 3D Lenticular Sports Cards

These cards shifted images when tilted which made them a hit with young collectors in the 1990s. Many cards ended up scratched because the surface was easy to damage. A clean card without scuffs can reach around $20.

Unopened packs from old cereal boxes attract more attention since the condition is guaranteed. Complete runs from one release year carry stronger value among collectors. A sealed pack may reach around $60.

Apple Jacks Mini Flip Books

Select boxes included tiny flip books showing short animated scenes featuring the mascots. The thin paper covers tore easily which makes clean copies rare. A single flip book in smooth condition can reach around $35.

Collectors enjoy finding sets that include multiple storylines from that era. Items without creases or loose pages carry stronger value. A complete mini set can reach around $90.

Cinnamon Toast Crunch 1990s Hologram Character Cards

These shiny hologram cards reflected light in different ways which made them popular during the early hologram trend. Many were carried around in pockets which caused scratches and bends. Cards that remain clean and flat can reach around $25.

Collectors focus on cards with strong hologram clarity. Sets stored in protective sleeves from the start tend to draw more interest. A full set in clean condition can reach around $110.

Franken Berry Character Mask Insert

This cardboard mask could be punched out and worn with a string during Halloween season. Most masks were used for play which left tears around the eye holes and edges. A clean, unpunched mask can reach around $60.

Collectors appreciate masks that still show bold artwork and clean outlines. Boxes that still hold the mask inside are even more difficult to find. A box with the mask untouched can reach around $150.

This article originally appeared on Avocadu.